PMC:2791889 / 5900-8905
Annnotations
bionlp-st-ge-2016-uniprot
{"project":"bionlp-st-ge-2016-uniprot","denotations":[{"id":"T3507","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3508","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3509","span":{"begin":78,"end":83},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3510","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"P01579"},{"id":"T3511","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3512","span":{"begin":205,"end":208},"obj":"P01730"},{"id":"T3513","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"E2RVI8"},{"id":"T3514","span":{"begin":295,"end":298},"obj":"E2RVI8"},{"id":"T3515","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"P01579"},{"id":"T3516","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3517","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"P05112"},{"id":"T3518","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3519","span":{"begin":681,"end":684},"obj":"P01730"},{"id":"T3520","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"P04234"},{"id":"T3521","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"P07766"},{"id":"T3522","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"P20963"},{"id":"T3523","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"P09693"},{"id":"T3524","span":{"begin":754,"end":758},"obj":"P10747"},{"id":"T3525","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3526","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3527","span":{"begin":807,"end":812},"obj":"P01579"},{"id":"T3528","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3529","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"P05112"},{"id":"T3530","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3531","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3532","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3533","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3534","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1127},"obj":"P01730"},{"id":"T3535","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3536","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3537","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3538","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3539","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"P01579"},{"id":"T3540","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3541","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3542","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3543","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3544","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3545","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3546","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1583},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3547","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3548","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3549","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3550","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3551","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3552","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"P01579"},{"id":"T3553","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"P60568"},{"id":"T3554","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3555","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3556","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1966},"obj":"P01730"},{"id":"T3557","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3558","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2097},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3559","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"P60568"},{"id":"T3560","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2167},"obj":"P01730"},{"id":"T3561","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3562","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3563","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3564","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"P01137"},{"id":"T3565","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3566","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2543},"obj":"P01730"},{"id":"T3567","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"P01137"},{"id":"T3568","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3569","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2817},"obj":"P22301"},{"id":"T3570","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"P29459"},{"id":"T3571","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"P29460"},{"id":"T3572","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"P60568"},{"id":"T3573","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"P01137"}],"namespaces":[{"prefix":"_base","uri":"http://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
bionlp-st-ge-2016-reference
{"project":"bionlp-st-ge-2016-reference","denotations":[{"id":"T2869","span":{"begin":295,"end":298},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2870","span":{"begin":352,"end":356},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2871","span":{"begin":352,"end":356},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2872","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2873","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2874","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2875","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2876","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2877","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2878","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2879","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2880","span":{"begin":681,"end":684},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2881","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2882","span":{"begin":754,"end":758},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2883","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2884","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2885","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2886","span":{"begin":807,"end":812},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2887","span":{"begin":813,"end":822},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2888","span":{"begin":856,"end":866},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2889","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2890","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2891","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2892","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2893","span":{"begin":977,"end":985},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2894","span":{"begin":999,"end":1007},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2895","span":{"begin":1013,"end":1023},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2896","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2897","span":{"begin":1033,"end":1043},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2898","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2899","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1127},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2900","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2901","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2902","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2903","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2904","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2905","span":{"begin":1300,"end":1310},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2906","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2907","span":{"begin":1340,"end":1350},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2908","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2909","span":{"begin":1403,"end":1409},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2910","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2911","span":{"begin":1428,"end":1438},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2912","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2913","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1583},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2914","span":{"begin":1584,"end":1593},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2915","span":{"begin":1616,"end":1624},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2916","span":{"begin":1625,"end":1629},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2917","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2918","span":{"begin":1719,"end":1728},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2919","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2920","span":{"begin":1735,"end":1743},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2921","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2922","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2923","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2924","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2925","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2926","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2927","span":{"begin":1878,"end":1885},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2928","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2929","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2930","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1966},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2931","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2932","span":{"begin":2056,"end":2066},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2933","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2097},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2934","span":{"begin":2098,"end":2107},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2935","span":{"begin":2144,"end":2151},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2936","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2937","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2167},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2938","span":{"begin":2190,"end":2221},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2939","span":{"begin":2223,"end":2227},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2940","span":{"begin":2229,"end":2238},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2941","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2942","span":{"begin":2315,"end":2323},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2943","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2944","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2945","span":{"begin":2395,"end":2404},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2946","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2947","span":{"begin":2524,"end":2530},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2948","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2949","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2543},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2950","span":{"begin":2693,"end":2707},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2951","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2952","span":{"begin":2724,"end":2733},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2953","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2954","span":{"begin":2740,"end":2750},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2955","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2817},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2956","span":{"begin":2818,"end":2827},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2957","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2958","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2959","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2960","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2961","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2962","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2860","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2861","span":{"begin":68,"end":77},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2862","span":{"begin":78,"end":83},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2863","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2864","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2865","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2866","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2867","span":{"begin":205,"end":208},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2868","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"Protein"}],"relations":[{"id":"R2157","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2897","obj":"T2895"},{"id":"R2158","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2901","obj":"T2902"},{"id":"R2159","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2901","obj":"T2903"},{"id":"R2160","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2904","obj":"T2905"},{"id":"R2161","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2905","obj":"T2902"},{"id":"R2162","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2906","obj":"T2907"},{"id":"R2163","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2907","obj":"T2903"},{"id":"R2164","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2908","obj":"T2909"},{"id":"R2165","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2910","obj":"T2911"},{"id":"R2166","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2911","obj":"T2909"},{"id":"R2167","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2913","obj":"T2914"},{"id":"R2168","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2915","obj":"T2916"},{"id":"R2169","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2917","obj":"T2915"},{"id":"R2170","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2918","obj":"T2920"},{"id":"R2171","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2919","obj":"T2918"},{"id":"R2172","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2921","obj":"T2920"},{"id":"R2173","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2924","obj":"T2922"},{"id":"R2174","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2925","obj":"T2923"},{"id":"R2175","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2927","obj":"T2926"},{"id":"R2140","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2872","obj":"T2870"},{"id":"R2141","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2873","obj":"T2871"},{"id":"R2142","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2874","obj":"T2873"},{"id":"R2143","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2875","obj":"T2872"},{"id":"R2144","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2878","obj":"T2877"},{"id":"R2145","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2879","obj":"T2876"},{"id":"R2146","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2883","obj":"T2885"},{"id":"R2147","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2883","obj":"T2884"},{"id":"R2148","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2886","obj":"T2887"},{"id":"R2149","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2887","obj":"T2885"},{"id":"R2150","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2888","obj":"T2884"},{"id":"R2151","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2889","obj":"T2888"},{"id":"R2152","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2891","obj":"T2894"},{"id":"R2153","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2892","obj":"T2891"},{"id":"R2154","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2892","obj":"T2893"},{"id":"R2155","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2895","obj":"T2894"},{"id":"R2156","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2896","obj":"T2897"},{"id":"R2136","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2862","obj":"T2861"},{"id":"R2137","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2865","obj":"T2864"},{"id":"R2138","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2866","obj":"T2863"},{"id":"R2139","pred":"equivalentTo","subj":"T2869","obj":"T2868"},{"id":"R2176","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2928","obj":"T2927"},{"id":"R2177","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2931","obj":"T2932"},{"id":"R2178","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2933","obj":"T2934"},{"id":"R2179","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2936","obj":"T2935"},{"id":"R2180","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2938","obj":"T2940"},{"id":"R2181","pred":"equivalentTo","subj":"T2939","obj":"T2938"},{"id":"R2182","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2941","obj":"T2942"},{"id":"R2183","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2943","obj":"T2944"},{"id":"R2184","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2944","obj":"T2942"},{"id":"R2185","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2944","obj":"T2945"},{"id":"R2186","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2946","obj":"T2947"},{"id":"R2187","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2948","obj":"T2947"},{"id":"R2188","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2950","obj":"T2952"},{"id":"R2189","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2951","obj":"T2950"},{"id":"R2190","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2953","obj":"T2954"},{"id":"R2191","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2954","obj":"T2952"},{"id":"R2192","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2955","obj":"T2956"},{"id":"R2193","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2956","obj":"T2958"},{"id":"R2194","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2956","obj":"T2957"},{"id":"R2195","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2956","obj":"T2959"},{"id":"R2196","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2960","obj":"T2958"},{"id":"R2197","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2961","obj":"T2957"},{"id":"R2198","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2962","obj":"T2959"}],"attributes":[{"id":"M35","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2957","obj":"true"},{"id":"M33","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2945","obj":"true"},{"id":"M30","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T2894","obj":"true"},{"id":"M36","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2959","obj":"true"},{"id":"M34","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T2947","obj":"true"},{"id":"M31","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2909","obj":"true"},{"id":"M32","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T2909","obj":"true"},{"id":"M29","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2872","obj":"true"}],"namespaces":[{"prefix":"_base","uri":"http://bionlp.dbcls.jp/ontology/ge.owl#"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
2_test
{"project":"2_test","denotations":[{"id":"19646904-7595230-46582684","span":{"begin":445,"end":449},"obj":"7595230"},{"id":"19646904-7595228-46582684","span":{"begin":445,"end":449},"obj":"7595228"},{"id":"19646904-14557415-46582685","span":{"begin":2591,"end":2595},"obj":"14557415"},{"id":"19646904-10880840-46582685","span":{"begin":2591,"end":2595},"obj":"10880840"},{"id":"T10777","span":{"begin":445,"end":449},"obj":"7595230"},{"id":"T18378","span":{"begin":445,"end":449},"obj":"7595228"},{"id":"T24066","span":{"begin":2591,"end":2595},"obj":"14557415"},{"id":"T49812","span":{"begin":2591,"end":2595},"obj":"10880840"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
pmc-enju-pas
{"project":"pmc-enju-pas","denotations":[{"id":"T2978","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2979","span":{"begin":6,"end":9},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T2980","span":{"begin":10,"end":14},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T2981","span":{"begin":15,"end":20},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2982","span":{"begin":21,"end":23},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T2983","span":{"begin":24,"end":31},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2984","span":{"begin":32,"end":38},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T2985","span":{"begin":39,"end":42},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T2986","span":{"begin":43,"end":54},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2987","span":{"begin":55,"end":57},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T2988","span":{"begin":58,"end":61},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2989","span":{"begin":62,"end":67},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2990","span":{"begin":68,"end":77},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T2991","span":{"begin":78,"end":83},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2992","span":{"begin":84,"end":86},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T2993","span":{"begin":87,"end":92},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T2994","span":{"begin":93,"end":96},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T2995","span":{"begin":97,"end":112},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2996","span":{"begin":113,"end":115},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T2997","span":{"begin":116,"end":119},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2998","span":{"begin":120,"end":125},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T2999","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3000","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3001","span":{"begin":144,"end":147},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3002","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3003","span":{"begin":153,"end":154},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3004","span":{"begin":155,"end":157},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T3005","span":{"begin":158,"end":166},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3006","span":{"begin":167,"end":175},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3007","span":{"begin":176,"end":190},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3008","span":{"begin":191,"end":198},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3009","span":{"begin":199,"end":204},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3010","span":{"begin":205,"end":209},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3011","span":{"begin":210,"end":217},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3012","span":{"begin":218,"end":222},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3013","span":{"begin":223,"end":231},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3014","span":{"begin":232,"end":235},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3015","span":{"begin":236,"end":238},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3016","span":{"begin":239,"end":243},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3017","span":{"begin":244,"end":247},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3018","span":{"begin":248,"end":258},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3019","span":{"begin":259,"end":264},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3020","span":{"begin":265,"end":267},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3021","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3022","span":{"begin":278,"end":285},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3023","span":{"begin":286,"end":293},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3024","span":{"begin":294,"end":295},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3025","span":{"begin":295,"end":298},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3026","span":{"begin":298,"end":299},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3027","span":{"begin":301,"end":308},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3028","span":{"begin":309,"end":313},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3029","span":{"begin":314,"end":318},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3030","span":{"begin":319,"end":324},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3031","span":{"begin":325,"end":327},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3032","span":{"begin":328,"end":335},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3033","span":{"begin":336,"end":339},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3034","span":{"begin":340,"end":341},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3035","span":{"begin":342,"end":346},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3036","span":{"begin":347,"end":351},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3037","span":{"begin":352,"end":356},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3038","span":{"begin":357,"end":359},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3039","span":{"begin":360,"end":363},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3040","span":{"begin":364,"end":369},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3041","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3042","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3043","span":{"begin":387,"end":391},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3044","span":{"begin":392,"end":405},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3045","span":{"begin":406,"end":407},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3046","span":{"begin":407,"end":415},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3047","span":{"begin":416,"end":422},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3048","span":{"begin":422,"end":423},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3049","span":{"begin":424,"end":428},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3050","span":{"begin":428,"end":429},"obj":"-COLON-"},{"id":"T3051","span":{"begin":430,"end":436},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3052","span":{"begin":437,"end":443},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3053","span":{"begin":443,"end":444},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3054","span":{"begin":445,"end":449},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3055","span":{"begin":449,"end":450},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3056","span":{"begin":450,"end":451},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3057","span":{"begin":452,"end":455},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3058","span":{"begin":456,"end":459},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3059","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3060","span":{"begin":466,"end":467},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3061","span":{"begin":467,"end":477},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3062","span":{"begin":478,"end":487},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3063","span":{"begin":488,"end":494},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3064","span":{"begin":494,"end":495},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3065","span":{"begin":497,"end":504},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3066","span":{"begin":505,"end":509},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3067","span":{"begin":510,"end":513},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3068","span":{"begin":514,"end":521},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3069","span":{"begin":522,"end":527},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3070","span":{"begin":528,"end":533},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3071","span":{"begin":534,"end":537},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3072","span":{"begin":538,"end":542},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3073","span":{"begin":543,"end":553},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3074","span":{"begin":554,"end":557},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3075","span":{"begin":558,"end":560},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3076","span":{"begin":561,"end":564},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3077","span":{"begin":565,"end":580},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3078","span":{"begin":581,"end":583},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3079","span":{"begin":584,"end":587},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3080","span":{"begin":588,"end":593},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3081","span":{"begin":593,"end":594},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3082","span":{"begin":595,"end":600},"obj":"WDT"},{"id":"T3083","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3084","span":{"begin":611,"end":615},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3085","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3086","span":{"begin":621,"end":624},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3087","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3088","span":{"begin":631,"end":635},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3089","span":{"begin":636,"end":649},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3090","span":{"begin":650,"end":651},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3091","span":{"begin":651,"end":661},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3092","span":{"begin":661,"end":662},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3093","span":{"begin":664,"end":671},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3094","span":{"begin":672,"end":674},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3095","span":{"begin":675,"end":680},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3096","span":{"begin":681,"end":685},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3097","span":{"begin":686,"end":693},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3098","span":{"begin":694,"end":696},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3099","span":{"begin":697,"end":699},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3100","span":{"begin":700,"end":708},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3101","span":{"begin":709,"end":715},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3102","span":{"begin":716,"end":718},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3103","span":{"begin":719,"end":730},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3104","span":{"begin":731,"end":735},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3105","span":{"begin":736,"end":744},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3106","span":{"begin":745,"end":748},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3107","span":{"begin":749,"end":758},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3108","span":{"begin":759,"end":769},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3109","span":{"begin":770,"end":772},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3110","span":{"begin":773,"end":776},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3111","span":{"begin":777,"end":785},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3112","span":{"begin":786,"end":788},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3113","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3114","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3115","span":{"begin":804,"end":806},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3116","span":{"begin":807,"end":822},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3117","span":{"begin":823,"end":826},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3118","span":{"begin":827,"end":832},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3119","span":{"begin":832,"end":833},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3120","span":{"begin":834,"end":835},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3121","span":{"begin":836,"end":846},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3122","span":{"begin":847,"end":849},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3123","span":{"begin":850,"end":855},"obj":"WDT"},{"id":"T3124","span":{"begin":856,"end":866},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3125","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3126","span":{"begin":872,"end":873},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3127","span":{"begin":874,"end":876},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3128","span":{"begin":877,"end":880},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3129","span":{"begin":881,"end":884},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3130","span":{"begin":885,"end":890},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3131","span":{"begin":891,"end":900},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3132","span":{"begin":901,"end":905},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3133","span":{"begin":906,"end":913},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3134","span":{"begin":914,"end":916},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3135","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3136","span":{"begin":922,"end":923},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3137","span":{"begin":923,"end":933},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3138","span":{"begin":933,"end":934},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3139","span":{"begin":936,"end":938},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3140","span":{"begin":939,"end":950},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3141","span":{"begin":951,"end":958},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3142","span":{"begin":959,"end":962},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3143","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3144","span":{"begin":968,"end":970},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3145","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3146","span":{"begin":977,"end":985},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3147","span":{"begin":986,"end":988},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3148","span":{"begin":989,"end":992},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3149","span":{"begin":993,"end":998},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3150","span":{"begin":999,"end":1007},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3151","span":{"begin":1008,"end":1012},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3152","span":{"begin":1013,"end":1023},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3153","span":{"begin":1024,"end":1026},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3154","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3155","span":{"begin":1033,"end":1043},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3156","span":{"begin":1044,"end":1046},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3157","span":{"begin":1047,"end":1050},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3158","span":{"begin":1051,"end":1054},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3159","span":{"begin":1055,"end":1059},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3160","span":{"begin":1060,"end":1067},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3161","span":{"begin":1068,"end":1072},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3162","span":{"begin":1073,"end":1075},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3163","span":{"begin":1076,"end":1089},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3164","span":{"begin":1090,"end":1098},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3165","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3166","span":{"begin":1104,"end":1105},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3167","span":{"begin":1106,"end":1108},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T3168","span":{"begin":1109,"end":1117},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3169","span":{"begin":1118,"end":1123},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3170","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1128},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3171","span":{"begin":1129,"end":1136},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3172","span":{"begin":1137,"end":1141},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3173","span":{"begin":1142,"end":1152},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3174","span":{"begin":1153,"end":1158},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3175","span":{"begin":1159,"end":1161},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3176","span":{"begin":1162,"end":1169},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3177","span":{"begin":1170,"end":1179},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3178","span":{"begin":1180,"end":1182},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3179","span":{"begin":1183,"end":1185},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3180","span":{"begin":1186,"end":1188},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3181","span":{"begin":1189,"end":1192},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3182","span":{"begin":1193,"end":1201},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3183","span":{"begin":1202,"end":1204},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3184","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3185","span":{"begin":1212,"end":1214},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3186","span":{"begin":1215,"end":1218},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3187","span":{"begin":1219,"end":1224},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3188","span":{"begin":1225,"end":1227},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3189","span":{"begin":1228,"end":1235},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3190","span":{"begin":1235,"end":1236},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3191","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3192","span":{"begin":1243,"end":1252},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3193","span":{"begin":1253,"end":1256},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3194","span":{"begin":1257,"end":1268},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3195","span":{"begin":1269,"end":1271},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3196","span":{"begin":1272,"end":1275},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3197","span":{"begin":1276,"end":1281},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3198","span":{"begin":1282,"end":1285},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3199","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3200","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3201","span":{"begin":1300,"end":1310},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3202","span":{"begin":1311,"end":1314},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3203","span":{"begin":1315,"end":1319},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3204","span":{"begin":1320,"end":1323},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3205","span":{"begin":1324,"end":1330},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3206","span":{"begin":1331,"end":1333},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3207","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3208","span":{"begin":1340,"end":1350},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3209","span":{"begin":1350,"end":1351},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3210","span":{"begin":1352,"end":1362},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3211","span":{"begin":1363,"end":1367},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3212","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3213","span":{"begin":1374,"end":1377},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3214","span":{"begin":1378,"end":1380},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3215","span":{"begin":1381,"end":1384},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3216","span":{"begin":1385,"end":1388},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3217","span":{"begin":1389,"end":1399},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3218","span":{"begin":1400,"end":1402},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3219","span":{"begin":1403,"end":1409},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3220","span":{"begin":1410,"end":1421},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3221","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3222","span":{"begin":1428,"end":1438},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3223","span":{"begin":1439,"end":1441},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3224","span":{"begin":1442,"end":1445},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3225","span":{"begin":1446,"end":1451},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3226","span":{"begin":1452,"end":1453},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3227","span":{"begin":1453,"end":1462},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3228","span":{"begin":1462,"end":1463},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3229","span":{"begin":1465,"end":1475},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3230","span":{"begin":1475,"end":1476},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3231","span":{"begin":1477,"end":1479},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3232","span":{"begin":1480,"end":1483},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3233","span":{"begin":1484,"end":1491},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3234","span":{"begin":1492,"end":1496},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3235","span":{"begin":1497,"end":1500},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3236","span":{"begin":1501,"end":1510},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3237","span":{"begin":1510,"end":1511},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3238","span":{"begin":1512,"end":1515},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3239","span":{"begin":1516,"end":1527},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3240","span":{"begin":1528,"end":1534},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3241","span":{"begin":1535,"end":1539},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3242","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3243","span":{"begin":1546,"end":1549},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3244","span":{"begin":1550,"end":1559},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3245","span":{"begin":1560,"end":1566},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3246","span":{"begin":1567,"end":1574},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3247","span":{"begin":1575,"end":1577},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3248","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1593},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3249","span":{"begin":1594,"end":1599},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3250","span":{"begin":1600,"end":1601},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3251","span":{"begin":1601,"end":1610},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3252","span":{"begin":1610,"end":1611},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3253","span":{"begin":1612,"end":1615},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3254","span":{"begin":1616,"end":1624},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3255","span":{"begin":1625,"end":1629},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3256","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3257","span":{"begin":1636,"end":1643},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3258","span":{"begin":1644,"end":1648},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3259","span":{"begin":1649,"end":1662},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3260","span":{"begin":1663,"end":1664},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3261","span":{"begin":1664,"end":1671},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3262","span":{"begin":1672,"end":1674},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3263","span":{"begin":1675,"end":1678},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3264","span":{"begin":1679,"end":1681},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3265","span":{"begin":1681,"end":1682},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3266","span":{"begin":1684,"end":1688},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3267","span":{"begin":1688,"end":1689},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3268","span":{"begin":1690,"end":1693},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3269","span":{"begin":1694,"end":1705},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3270","span":{"begin":1706,"end":1708},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3271","span":{"begin":1709,"end":1712},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3272","span":{"begin":1713,"end":1718},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3273","span":{"begin":1719,"end":1728},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3274","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3275","span":{"begin":1735,"end":1743},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3276","span":{"begin":1744,"end":1748},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3277","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3278","span":{"begin":1755,"end":1758},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3279","span":{"begin":1759,"end":1763},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3280","span":{"begin":1764,"end":1769},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3281","span":{"begin":1770,"end":1772},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3282","span":{"begin":1773,"end":1780},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3283","span":{"begin":1782,"end":1785},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3284","span":{"begin":1786,"end":1791},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3285","span":{"begin":1792,"end":1806},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3286","span":{"begin":1807,"end":1809},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3287","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3288","span":{"begin":1818,"end":1823},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3289","span":{"begin":1824,"end":1831},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3290","span":{"begin":1832,"end":1834},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3291","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3292","span":{"begin":1841,"end":1844},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3293","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3294","span":{"begin":1851,"end":1854},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3295","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3296","span":{"begin":1860,"end":1874},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3297","span":{"begin":1875,"end":1877},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3298","span":{"begin":1878,"end":1885},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3299","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3300","span":{"begin":1891,"end":1892},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3301","span":{"begin":1892,"end":1901},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3302","span":{"begin":1901,"end":1902},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3303","span":{"begin":1904,"end":1911},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3304","span":{"begin":1912,"end":1915},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3305","span":{"begin":1916,"end":1924},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3306","span":{"begin":1925,"end":1927},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3307","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3308","span":{"begin":1934,"end":1941},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3309","span":{"begin":1942,"end":1945},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3310","span":{"begin":1946,"end":1959},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3311","span":{"begin":1960,"end":1962},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3312","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1967},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3313","span":{"begin":1968,"end":1975},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3314","span":{"begin":1976,"end":1978},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3315","span":{"begin":1979,"end":1983},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3316","span":{"begin":1984,"end":1988},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3317","span":{"begin":1989,"end":1996},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3318","span":{"begin":1997,"end":2004},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3319","span":{"begin":2005,"end":2010},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3320","span":{"begin":2011,"end":2012},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3321","span":{"begin":2012,"end":2017},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3322","span":{"begin":2018,"end":2020},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3323","span":{"begin":2020,"end":2021},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3324","span":{"begin":2021,"end":2022},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3325","span":{"begin":2023,"end":2026},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3326","span":{"begin":2027,"end":2031},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3327","span":{"begin":2032,"end":2035},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3328","span":{"begin":2036,"end":2042},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3329","span":{"begin":2043,"end":2049},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3330","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3331","span":{"begin":2056,"end":2066},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3332","span":{"begin":2066,"end":2067},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3333","span":{"begin":2068,"end":2071},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3334","span":{"begin":2072,"end":2083},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3335","span":{"begin":2084,"end":2086},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3336","span":{"begin":2087,"end":2091},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3337","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2107},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3338","span":{"begin":2108,"end":2116},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3339","span":{"begin":2117,"end":2121},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3340","span":{"begin":2122,"end":2128},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3341","span":{"begin":2129,"end":2132},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3342","span":{"begin":2133,"end":2140},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3343","span":{"begin":2141,"end":2143},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3344","span":{"begin":2144,"end":2151},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3345","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3346","span":{"begin":2158,"end":2163},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3347","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2168},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3348","span":{"begin":2169,"end":2176},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3349","span":{"begin":2177,"end":2181},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3350","span":{"begin":2182,"end":2214},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3351","span":{"begin":2215,"end":2219},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3352","span":{"begin":2220,"end":2221},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3353","span":{"begin":2222,"end":2223},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3354","span":{"begin":2223,"end":2227},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3355","span":{"begin":2227,"end":2228},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3356","span":{"begin":2228,"end":2238},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3357","span":{"begin":2239,"end":2246},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3358","span":{"begin":2246,"end":2247},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3359","span":{"begin":2248,"end":2256},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3360","span":{"begin":2257,"end":2261},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3361","span":{"begin":2262,"end":2266},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3362","span":{"begin":2267,"end":2272},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3363","span":{"begin":2273,"end":2275},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3364","span":{"begin":2276,"end":2283},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3365","span":{"begin":2284,"end":2286},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3366","span":{"begin":2287,"end":2290},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3367","span":{"begin":2291,"end":2299},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3368","span":{"begin":2300,"end":2302},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3369","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3370","span":{"begin":2308,"end":2309},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3371","span":{"begin":2310,"end":2314},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3372","span":{"begin":2315,"end":2323},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3373","span":{"begin":2324,"end":2326},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3374","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3375","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3376","span":{"begin":2344,"end":2346},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3377","span":{"begin":2347,"end":2350},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3378","span":{"begin":2351,"end":2356},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3379","span":{"begin":2356,"end":2357},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3380","span":{"begin":2358,"end":2365},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3381","span":{"begin":2366,"end":2370},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3382","span":{"begin":2371,"end":2375},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3383","span":{"begin":2376,"end":2386},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3384","span":{"begin":2387,"end":2390},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3385","span":{"begin":2391,"end":2394},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3386","span":{"begin":2395,"end":2404},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3387","span":{"begin":2405,"end":2407},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3388","span":{"begin":2408,"end":2411},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3389","span":{"begin":2412,"end":2420},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3390","span":{"begin":2421,"end":2423},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3391","span":{"begin":2424,"end":2432},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3392","span":{"begin":2433,"end":2435},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3393","span":{"begin":2436,"end":2442},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3394","span":{"begin":2443,"end":2450},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3395","span":{"begin":2451,"end":2453},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3396","span":{"begin":2454,"end":2458},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3397","span":{"begin":2459,"end":2464},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3398","span":{"begin":2465,"end":2466},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3399","span":{"begin":2466,"end":2475},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3400","span":{"begin":2475,"end":2476},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3401","span":{"begin":2478,"end":2486},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3402","span":{"begin":2487,"end":2489},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T3403","span":{"begin":2490,"end":2493},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3404","span":{"begin":2494,"end":2498},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3405","span":{"begin":2499,"end":2508},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3406","span":{"begin":2509,"end":2513},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3407","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3408","span":{"begin":2520,"end":2523},"obj":"MD"},{"id":"T3409","span":{"begin":2524,"end":2530},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3410","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3411","span":{"begin":2537,"end":2539},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3412","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2544},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3413","span":{"begin":2545,"end":2552},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3414","span":{"begin":2553,"end":2554},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3415","span":{"begin":2554,"end":2560},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3416","span":{"begin":2561,"end":2567},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3417","span":{"begin":2567,"end":2568},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3418","span":{"begin":2569,"end":2573},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3419","span":{"begin":2573,"end":2574},"obj":"-COLON-"},{"id":"T3420","span":{"begin":2575,"end":2582},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3421","span":{"begin":2583,"end":2589},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3422","span":{"begin":2589,"end":2590},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3423","span":{"begin":2591,"end":2595},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3424","span":{"begin":2595,"end":2596},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3425","span":{"begin":2596,"end":2597},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3426","span":{"begin":2598,"end":2600},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T3427","span":{"begin":2601,"end":2606},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3428","span":{"begin":2607,"end":2611},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3429","span":{"begin":2612,"end":2614},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3430","span":{"begin":2615,"end":2625},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3431","span":{"begin":2626,"end":2629},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3432","span":{"begin":2630,"end":2633},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3433","span":{"begin":2634,"end":2637},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3434","span":{"begin":2638,"end":2643},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3435","span":{"begin":2644,"end":2648},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3436","span":{"begin":2649,"end":2652},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3437","span":{"begin":2653,"end":2656},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3438","span":{"begin":2657,"end":2660},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3439","span":{"begin":2661,"end":2665},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3440","span":{"begin":2666,"end":2667},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3441","span":{"begin":2667,"end":2671},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3442","span":{"begin":2672,"end":2675},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3443","span":{"begin":2676,"end":2681},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3444","span":{"begin":2681,"end":2682},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3445","span":{"begin":2684,"end":2686},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3446","span":{"begin":2687,"end":2691},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3447","span":{"begin":2691,"end":2692},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3448","span":{"begin":2693,"end":2707},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3449","span":{"begin":2708,"end":2710},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3450","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3451","span":{"begin":2717,"end":2720},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3452","span":{"begin":2721,"end":2723},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3453","span":{"begin":2724,"end":2733},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3454","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3455","span":{"begin":2740,"end":2750},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3456","span":{"begin":2751,"end":2753},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3457","span":{"begin":2754,"end":2758},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3458","span":{"begin":2759,"end":2765},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3459","span":{"begin":2766,"end":2773},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3460","span":{"begin":2774,"end":2775},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3461","span":{"begin":2775,"end":2784},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3462","span":{"begin":2784,"end":2785},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3463","span":{"begin":2787,"end":2791},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3464","span":{"begin":2791,"end":2792},"obj":"-COMMA-"},{"id":"T3465","span":{"begin":2793,"end":2796},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3466","span":{"begin":2797,"end":2808},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3467","span":{"begin":2809,"end":2811},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3468","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2827},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3469","span":{"begin":2828,"end":2831},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3470","span":{"begin":2832,"end":2837},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3471","span":{"begin":2838,"end":2842},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3472","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3473","span":{"begin":2852,"end":2854},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3474","span":{"begin":2855,"end":2858},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3475","span":{"begin":2859,"end":2867},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3476","span":{"begin":2868,"end":2870},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3477","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3478","span":{"begin":2877,"end":2885},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3479","span":{"begin":2886,"end":2890},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3480","span":{"begin":2891,"end":2895},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3481","span":{"begin":2896,"end":2903},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3482","span":{"begin":2904,"end":2908},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3483","span":{"begin":2909,"end":2912},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3484","span":{"begin":2913,"end":2916},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3485","span":{"begin":2917,"end":2919},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3486","span":{"begin":2920,"end":2925},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3487","span":{"begin":2926,"end":2933},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3488","span":{"begin":2934,"end":2941},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3489","span":{"begin":2942,"end":2946},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3490","span":{"begin":2947,"end":2949},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3491","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3492","span":{"begin":2955,"end":2957},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3493","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3494","span":{"begin":2964,"end":2966},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3495","span":{"begin":2967,"end":2969},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3496","span":{"begin":2970,"end":2973},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3497","span":{"begin":2974,"end":2982},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3498","span":{"begin":2983,"end":2985},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3499","span":{"begin":2986,"end":2991},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3500","span":{"begin":2992,"end":2998},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3501","span":{"begin":2999,"end":3004},"obj":"NN"}],"relations":[{"id":"R2199","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2978","obj":"T2979"},{"id":"R2200","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2979","obj":"T2984"},{"id":"R2201","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2981","obj":"T2979"},{"id":"R2202","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2981","obj":"T2980"},{"id":"R2203","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2981","obj":"T2982"},{"id":"R2204","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2983","obj":"T2982"},{"id":"R2205","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2986","obj":"T2984"},{"id":"R2206","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2986","obj":"T2985"},{"id":"R2207","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2986","obj":"T2987"},{"id":"R2208","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2989","obj":"T2987"},{"id":"R2209","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2989","obj":"T2988"},{"id":"R2210","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2989","obj":"T2990"},{"id":"R2211","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2991","obj":"T2990"},{"id":"R2212","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2993","obj":"T2992"},{"id":"R2213","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2995","obj":"T2993"},{"id":"R2214","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2995","obj":"T2994"},{"id":"R2215","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2995","obj":"T2996"},{"id":"R2216","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T2998","obj":"T2996"},{"id":"R2217","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2998","obj":"T2997"},{"id":"R2218","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T2998","obj":"T2999"},{"id":"R2219","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3000","obj":"T3001"},{"id":"R2220","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3001","obj":"T2999"},{"id":"R2221","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3002","obj":"T3001"},{"id":"R2222","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3004","obj":"T2993"},{"id":"R2223","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3004","obj":"T3005"},{"id":"R2224","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3005","obj":"T2992"},{"id":"R2225","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3005","obj":"T3003"},{"id":"R2226","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3005","obj":"T3012"},{"id":"R2227","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3009","obj":"T3007"},{"id":"R2228","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3009","obj":"T3008"},{"id":"R2229","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3011","obj":"T3005"},{"id":"R2230","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3011","obj":"T3006"},{"id":"R2231","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3011","obj":"T3009"},{"id":"R2232","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3011","obj":"T3010"},{"id":"R2233","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3014","obj":"T3012"},{"id":"R2234","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3014","obj":"T3013"},{"id":"R2235","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3014","obj":"T3015"},{"id":"R2236","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3016","obj":"T3017"},{"id":"R2237","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3017","obj":"T3015"},{"id":"R2238","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3019","obj":"T3017"},{"id":"R2239","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3019","obj":"T3018"},{"id":"R2240","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3019","obj":"T3020"},{"id":"R2241","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3022","obj":"T3020"},{"id":"R2242","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3022","obj":"T3021"},{"id":"R2243","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3022","obj":"T3023"},{"id":"R2244","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3022","obj":"T3024"},{"id":"R2245","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3025","obj":"T3024"},{"id":"R2246","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3026","obj":"T3024"},{"id":"R2247","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3027","obj":"T3028"},{"id":"R2248","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3027","obj":"T3033"},{"id":"R2249","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3027","obj":"T3036"},{"id":"R2250","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3030","obj":"T3028"},{"id":"R2251","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3030","obj":"T3029"},{"id":"R2252","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3030","obj":"T3031"},{"id":"R2253","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3032","obj":"T3031"},{"id":"R2254","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3035","obj":"T3033"},{"id":"R2255","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3035","obj":"T3034"},{"id":"R2256","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3037","obj":"T3036"},{"id":"R2257","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3040","obj":"T3039"},{"id":"R2258","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3040","obj":"T3041"},{"id":"R2259","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3040","obj":"T3045"},{"id":"R2260","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3040","obj":"T3057"},{"id":"R2261","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3041","obj":"T3043"},{"id":"R2262","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3042","obj":"T3041"},{"id":"R2263","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3044","obj":"T3043"},{"id":"R2264","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3047","obj":"T3045"},{"id":"R2265","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3047","obj":"T3046"},{"id":"R2266","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3047","obj":"T3048"},{"id":"R2267","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3047","obj":"T3050"},{"id":"R2268","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3049","obj":"T3048"},{"id":"R2269","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3051","obj":"T3050"},{"id":"R2270","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3051","obj":"T3052"},{"id":"R2271","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3051","obj":"T3053"},{"id":"R2272","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3054","obj":"T3053"},{"id":"R2273","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3055","obj":"T3045"},{"id":"R2274","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3057","obj":"T3036"},{"id":"R2275","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3057","obj":"T3038"},{"id":"R2276","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3057","obj":"T3056"},{"id":"R2277","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3059","obj":"T3057"},{"id":"R2278","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3059","obj":"T3058"},{"id":"R2279","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3059","obj":"T3060"},{"id":"R2280","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3063","obj":"T3060"},{"id":"R2281","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3063","obj":"T3061"},{"id":"R2282","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3063","obj":"T3062"},{"id":"R2283","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3064","obj":"T3060"},{"id":"R2284","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3065","obj":"T3066"},{"id":"R2285","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3065","obj":"T3074"},{"id":"R2286","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3069","obj":"T3066"},{"id":"R2287","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3069","obj":"T3067"},{"id":"R2288","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3069","obj":"T3068"},{"id":"R2289","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3069","obj":"T3070"},{"id":"R2290","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3073","obj":"T3070"},{"id":"R2291","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3073","obj":"T3071"},{"id":"R2292","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3073","obj":"T3072"},{"id":"R2293","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3074","obj":"T3075"},{"id":"R2294","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3077","obj":"T3075"},{"id":"R2295","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3077","obj":"T3076"},{"id":"R2296","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3077","obj":"T3078"},{"id":"R2297","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3080","obj":"T3078"},{"id":"R2298","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3080","obj":"T3079"},{"id":"R2299","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3080","obj":"T3081"},{"id":"R2300","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3080","obj":"T3082"},{"id":"R2301","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3080","obj":"T3083"},{"id":"R2302","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3083","obj":"T3088"},{"id":"R2303","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3085","obj":"T3086"},{"id":"R2304","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3086","obj":"T3083"},{"id":"R2305","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3086","obj":"T3084"},{"id":"R2306","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3087","obj":"T3086"},{"id":"R2307","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3089","obj":"T3088"},{"id":"R2308","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3089","obj":"T3090"},{"id":"R2309","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3091","obj":"T3090"},{"id":"R2310","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3092","obj":"T3090"},{"id":"R2311","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3093","obj":"T3094"},{"id":"R2312","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3093","obj":"T3098"},{"id":"R2313","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3093","obj":"T3114"},{"id":"R2314","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3097","obj":"T3094"},{"id":"R2315","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3097","obj":"T3095"},{"id":"R2316","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3097","obj":"T3096"},{"id":"R2317","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3101","obj":"T3098"},{"id":"R2318","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3101","obj":"T3099"},{"id":"R2319","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3101","obj":"T3100"},{"id":"R2320","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3101","obj":"T3102"},{"id":"R2321","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3103","obj":"T3102"},{"id":"R2322","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3103","obj":"T3104"},{"id":"R2323","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3105","obj":"T3106"},{"id":"R2324","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3107","obj":"T3106"},{"id":"R2325","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3108","obj":"T3104"},{"id":"R2326","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3108","obj":"T3105"},{"id":"R2327","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3108","obj":"T3107"},{"id":"R2328","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3108","obj":"T3109"},{"id":"R2329","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3111","obj":"T3109"},{"id":"R2330","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3111","obj":"T3110"},{"id":"R2331","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3111","obj":"T3112"},{"id":"R2332","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3113","obj":"T3112"},{"id":"R2333","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3114","obj":"T3115"},{"id":"R2334","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3118","obj":"T3115"},{"id":"R2335","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3118","obj":"T3116"},{"id":"R2336","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3118","obj":"T3117"},{"id":"R2337","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3118","obj":"T3122"},{"id":"R2338","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3118","obj":"T3123"},{"id":"R2339","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3121","obj":"T3120"},{"id":"R2340","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3121","obj":"T3122"},{"id":"R2341","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3121","obj":"T3124"},{"id":"R2342","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3124","obj":"T3119"},{"id":"R2343","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3124","obj":"T3126"},{"id":"R2344","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3124","obj":"T3127"},{"id":"R2345","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3125","obj":"T3124"},{"id":"R2346","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3128","obj":"T3127"},{"id":"R2347","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3130","obj":"T3128"},{"id":"R2348","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3130","obj":"T3129"},{"id":"R2349","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3130","obj":"T3131"},{"id":"R2350","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3131","obj":"T3132"},{"id":"R2351","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3131","obj":"T3134"},{"id":"R2352","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3133","obj":"T3132"},{"id":"R2353","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3135","obj":"T3134"},{"id":"R2354","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3135","obj":"T3136"},{"id":"R2355","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3137","obj":"T3136"},{"id":"R2356","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3138","obj":"T3136"},{"id":"R2357","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3140","obj":"T3139"},{"id":"R2358","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3143","obj":"T3142"},{"id":"R2359","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3143","obj":"T3144"},{"id":"R2360","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3143","obj":"T3150"},{"id":"R2361","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3145","obj":"T3144"},{"id":"R2362","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3145","obj":"T3146"},{"id":"R2363","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3149","obj":"T3146"},{"id":"R2364","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3149","obj":"T3147"},{"id":"R2365","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3149","obj":"T3148"},{"id":"R2366","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3150","obj":"T3140"},{"id":"R2367","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3150","obj":"T3141"},{"id":"R2368","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3150","obj":"T3151"},{"id":"R2369","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3152","obj":"T3153"},{"id":"R2370","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3152","obj":"T3158"},{"id":"R2371","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3155","obj":"T3153"},{"id":"R2372","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3155","obj":"T3154"},{"id":"R2373","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3155","obj":"T3156"},{"id":"R2374","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3157","obj":"T3156"},{"id":"R2375","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3158","obj":"T3151"},{"id":"R2376","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3161","obj":"T3159"},{"id":"R2377","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3161","obj":"T3160"},{"id":"R2378","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3161","obj":"T3162"},{"id":"R2379","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3162","obj":"T3158"},{"id":"R2380","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3165","obj":"T3162"},{"id":"R2381","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3165","obj":"T3163"},{"id":"R2382","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3165","obj":"T3164"},{"id":"R2383","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3167","obj":"T3140"},{"id":"R2384","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3167","obj":"T3168"},{"id":"R2385","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3168","obj":"T3139"},{"id":"R2386","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3168","obj":"T3166"},{"id":"R2387","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3171","obj":"T3168"},{"id":"R2388","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3171","obj":"T3169"},{"id":"R2389","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3171","obj":"T3170"},{"id":"R2390","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3171","obj":"T3172"},{"id":"R2391","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3174","obj":"T3172"},{"id":"R2392","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3174","obj":"T3173"},{"id":"R2393","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3174","obj":"T3175"},{"id":"R2394","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3174","obj":"T3177"},{"id":"R2395","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3176","obj":"T3175"},{"id":"R2396","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3177","obj":"T3180"},{"id":"R2397","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3179","obj":"T3177"},{"id":"R2398","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3179","obj":"T3178"},{"id":"R2399","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3182","obj":"T3180"},{"id":"R2400","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3182","obj":"T3181"},{"id":"R2401","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3182","obj":"T3183"},{"id":"R2402","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3184","obj":"T3183"},{"id":"R2403","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3187","obj":"T3185"},{"id":"R2404","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3187","obj":"T3186"},{"id":"R2405","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3187","obj":"T3188"},{"id":"R2406","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3189","obj":"T3188"},{"id":"R2407","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3191","obj":"T3192"},{"id":"R2408","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3191","obj":"T3199"},{"id":"R2409","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3192","obj":"T3198"},{"id":"R2410","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3194","obj":"T3192"},{"id":"R2411","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3194","obj":"T3193"},{"id":"R2412","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3194","obj":"T3195"},{"id":"R2413","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3197","obj":"T3195"},{"id":"R2414","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3197","obj":"T3196"},{"id":"R2415","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3198","obj":"T3185"},{"id":"R2416","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3198","obj":"T3190"},{"id":"R2417","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3199","obj":"T3198"},{"id":"R2418","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3199","obj":"T3209"},{"id":"R2419","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3199","obj":"T3210"},{"id":"R2420","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3201","obj":"T3200"},{"id":"R2421","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3201","obj":"T3202"},{"id":"R2422","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3202","obj":"T3199"},{"id":"R2423","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3202","obj":"T3206"},{"id":"R2424","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3205","obj":"T3202"},{"id":"R2425","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3205","obj":"T3203"},{"id":"R2426","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3205","obj":"T3204"},{"id":"R2427","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3208","obj":"T3206"},{"id":"R2428","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3208","obj":"T3207"},{"id":"R2429","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3212","obj":"T3214"},{"id":"R2430","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3212","obj":"T3215"},{"id":"R2431","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3212","obj":"T3217"},{"id":"R2432","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3214","obj":"T3213"},{"id":"R2433","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3215","obj":"T3210"},{"id":"R2434","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3215","obj":"T3211"},{"id":"R2435","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3215","obj":"T3216"},{"id":"R2436","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3215","obj":"T3218"},{"id":"R2437","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3217","obj":"T3215"},{"id":"R2438","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3219","obj":"T3218"},{"id":"R2439","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3219","obj":"T3223"},{"id":"R2440","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3222","obj":"T3219"},{"id":"R2441","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3222","obj":"T3220"},{"id":"R2442","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3222","obj":"T3221"},{"id":"R2443","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3225","obj":"T3223"},{"id":"R2444","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3225","obj":"T3224"},{"id":"R2445","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3225","obj":"T3226"},{"id":"R2446","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3227","obj":"T3226"},{"id":"R2447","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3228","obj":"T3226"},{"id":"R2448","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3234","obj":"T3232"},{"id":"R2449","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3234","obj":"T3233"},{"id":"R2450","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3234","obj":"T3235"},{"id":"R2451","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3234","obj":"T3236"},{"id":"R2452","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3236","obj":"T3231"},{"id":"R2453","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3236","obj":"T3235"},{"id":"R2454","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3239","obj":"T3238"},{"id":"R2455","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3239","obj":"T3240"},{"id":"R2456","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3239","obj":"T3244"},{"id":"R2457","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3239","obj":"T3254"},{"id":"R2458","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3240","obj":"T3241"},{"id":"R2459","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3242","obj":"T3241"},{"id":"R2460","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3244","obj":"T3253"},{"id":"R2461","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3246","obj":"T3244"},{"id":"R2462","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3246","obj":"T3245"},{"id":"R2463","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3246","obj":"T3247"},{"id":"R2464","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3249","obj":"T3247"},{"id":"R2465","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3249","obj":"T3248"},{"id":"R2466","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3249","obj":"T3250"},{"id":"R2467","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3251","obj":"T3250"},{"id":"R2468","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3252","obj":"T3250"},{"id":"R2469","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3253","obj":"T3229"},{"id":"R2470","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3253","obj":"T3230"},{"id":"R2471","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3253","obj":"T3231"},{"id":"R2472","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3253","obj":"T3237"},{"id":"R2473","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3253","obj":"T3243"},{"id":"R2474","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3254","obj":"T3253"},{"id":"R2475","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3254","obj":"T3258"},{"id":"R2476","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3257","obj":"T3254"},{"id":"R2477","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3257","obj":"T3255"},{"id":"R2478","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3257","obj":"T3256"},{"id":"R2479","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3259","obj":"T3258"},{"id":"R2480","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3259","obj":"T3260"},{"id":"R2481","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3262","obj":"T3263"},{"id":"R2482","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3263","obj":"T3260"},{"id":"R2483","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3263","obj":"T3261"},{"id":"R2484","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3264","obj":"T3263"},{"id":"R2485","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3265","obj":"T3260"},{"id":"R2486","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3269","obj":"T3268"},{"id":"R2487","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3269","obj":"T3270"},{"id":"R2488","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3269","obj":"T3275"},{"id":"R2489","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3272","obj":"T3270"},{"id":"R2490","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3272","obj":"T3271"},{"id":"R2491","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3272","obj":"T3273"},{"id":"R2492","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3274","obj":"T3273"},{"id":"R2493","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3275","obj":"T3266"},{"id":"R2494","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3275","obj":"T3267"},{"id":"R2495","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3277","obj":"T3278"},{"id":"R2496","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3278","obj":"T3275"},{"id":"R2497","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3278","obj":"T3276"},{"id":"R2498","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3280","obj":"T3278"},{"id":"R2499","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3280","obj":"T3279"},{"id":"R2500","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3280","obj":"T3281"},{"id":"R2501","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3282","obj":"T3281"},{"id":"R2502","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3284","obj":"T3283"},{"id":"R2503","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3284","obj":"T3285"},{"id":"R2504","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3285","obj":"T3286"},{"id":"R2505","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3287","obj":"T3294"},{"id":"R2506","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3289","obj":"T3287"},{"id":"R2507","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3289","obj":"T3288"},{"id":"R2508","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3289","obj":"T3290"},{"id":"R2509","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3291","obj":"T3292"},{"id":"R2510","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3292","obj":"T3290"},{"id":"R2511","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3293","obj":"T3292"},{"id":"R2512","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3294","obj":"T3286"},{"id":"R2513","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3295","obj":"T3294"},{"id":"R2514","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3296","obj":"T3295"},{"id":"R2515","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3296","obj":"T3297"},{"id":"R2516","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3298","obj":"T3297"},{"id":"R2517","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3299","obj":"T3298"},{"id":"R2518","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3299","obj":"T3300"},{"id":"R2519","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3301","obj":"T3300"},{"id":"R2520","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3302","obj":"T3300"},{"id":"R2521","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3305","obj":"T3304"},{"id":"R2522","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3305","obj":"T3306"},{"id":"R2523","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3305","obj":"T3308"},{"id":"R2524","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3307","obj":"T3306"},{"id":"R2525","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3308","obj":"T3314"},{"id":"R2526","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3308","obj":"T3325"},{"id":"R2527","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3310","obj":"T3308"},{"id":"R2528","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3310","obj":"T3309"},{"id":"R2529","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3310","obj":"T3311"},{"id":"R2530","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3313","obj":"T3311"},{"id":"R2531","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3313","obj":"T3312"},{"id":"R2532","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3319","obj":"T3314"},{"id":"R2533","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3319","obj":"T3315"},{"id":"R2534","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3319","obj":"T3316"},{"id":"R2535","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3319","obj":"T3317"},{"id":"R2536","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3319","obj":"T3318"},{"id":"R2537","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3319","obj":"T3320"},{"id":"R2538","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3322","obj":"T3320"},{"id":"R2539","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3322","obj":"T3321"},{"id":"R2540","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3323","obj":"T3320"},{"id":"R2541","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3325","obj":"T3303"},{"id":"R2542","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3325","obj":"T3324"},{"id":"R2543","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3328","obj":"T3326"},{"id":"R2544","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3328","obj":"T3327"},{"id":"R2545","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3328","obj":"T3329"},{"id":"R2546","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3329","obj":"T3325"},{"id":"R2547","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3331","obj":"T3329"},{"id":"R2548","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3331","obj":"T3330"},{"id":"R2549","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3331","obj":"T3332"},{"id":"R2550","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3334","obj":"T3332"},{"id":"R2551","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3334","obj":"T3333"},{"id":"R2552","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3334","obj":"T3335"},{"id":"R2553","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3338","obj":"T3335"},{"id":"R2554","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3338","obj":"T3336"},{"id":"R2555","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3338","obj":"T3337"},{"id":"R2556","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3338","obj":"T3342"},{"id":"R2557","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3340","obj":"T3339"},{"id":"R2558","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3342","obj":"T3340"},{"id":"R2559","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3342","obj":"T3341"},{"id":"R2560","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3342","obj":"T3343"},{"id":"R2561","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3345","obj":"T3343"},{"id":"R2562","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3345","obj":"T3344"},{"id":"R2563","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3348","obj":"T3346"},{"id":"R2564","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3348","obj":"T3347"},{"id":"R2565","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3348","obj":"T3349"},{"id":"R2566","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3348","obj":"T3358"},{"id":"R2567","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3348","obj":"T3359"},{"id":"R2568","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3348","obj":"T3372"},{"id":"R2569","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3354","obj":"T3353"},{"id":"R2570","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3355","obj":"T3353"},{"id":"R2571","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3357","obj":"T3349"},{"id":"R2572","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3357","obj":"T3350"},{"id":"R2573","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3357","obj":"T3351"},{"id":"R2574","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3357","obj":"T3352"},{"id":"R2575","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3357","obj":"T3353"},{"id":"R2576","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3357","obj":"T3356"},{"id":"R2577","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3359","obj":"T3360"},{"id":"R2578","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3362","obj":"T3360"},{"id":"R2579","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3362","obj":"T3361"},{"id":"R2580","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3362","obj":"T3363"},{"id":"R2581","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3362","obj":"T3365"},{"id":"R2582","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3364","obj":"T3363"},{"id":"R2583","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3367","obj":"T3365"},{"id":"R2584","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3367","obj":"T3366"},{"id":"R2585","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3367","obj":"T3368"},{"id":"R2586","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3369","obj":"T3368"},{"id":"R2587","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3372","obj":"T3370"},{"id":"R2588","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3372","obj":"T3371"},{"id":"R2589","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3372","obj":"T3373"},{"id":"R2590","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3372","obj":"T3379"},{"id":"R2591","pred":"modOf","subj":"T3372","obj":"T3380"},{"id":"R2592","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3375","obj":"T3373"},{"id":"R2593","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3375","obj":"T3374"},{"id":"R2594","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3375","obj":"T3376"},{"id":"R2595","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3378","obj":"T3376"},{"id":"R2596","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3378","obj":"T3377"},{"id":"R2597","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3383","obj":"T3382"},{"id":"R2598","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3383","obj":"T3384"},{"id":"R2599","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3383","obj":"T3386"},{"id":"R2600","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3384","obj":"T3380"},{"id":"R2601","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3384","obj":"T3381"},{"id":"R2602","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3384","obj":"T3385"},{"id":"R2603","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3386","obj":"T3384"},{"id":"R2604","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3386","obj":"T3387"},{"id":"R2605","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3389","obj":"T3387"},{"id":"R2606","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3389","obj":"T3388"},{"id":"R2607","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3389","obj":"T3390"},{"id":"R2608","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3391","obj":"T3392"},{"id":"R2609","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3393","obj":"T3392"},{"id":"R2610","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3394","obj":"T3391"},{"id":"R2611","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3394","obj":"T3393"},{"id":"R2612","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3394","obj":"T3395"},{"id":"R2613","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3395","obj":"T3390"},{"id":"R2614","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3397","obj":"T3395"},{"id":"R2615","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3397","obj":"T3396"},{"id":"R2616","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3397","obj":"T3398"},{"id":"R2617","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3399","obj":"T3398"},{"id":"R2618","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3400","obj":"T3398"},{"id":"R2619","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3402","obj":"T3403"},{"id":"R2620","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3402","obj":"T3404"},{"id":"R2621","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3402","obj":"T3405"},{"id":"R2622","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3405","obj":"T3401"},{"id":"R2623","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3405","obj":"T3403"},{"id":"R2624","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3405","obj":"T3404"},{"id":"R2625","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3407","obj":"T3408"},{"id":"R2626","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3407","obj":"T3409"},{"id":"R2627","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3409","obj":"T3405"},{"id":"R2628","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3409","obj":"T3406"},{"id":"R2629","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3409","obj":"T3408"},{"id":"R2630","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3410","obj":"T3409"},{"id":"R2631","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3410","obj":"T3411"},{"id":"R2632","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3413","obj":"T3411"},{"id":"R2633","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3413","obj":"T3412"},{"id":"R2634","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3413","obj":"T3414"},{"id":"R2635","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3416","obj":"T3415"},{"id":"R2636","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3416","obj":"T3417"},{"id":"R2637","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3416","obj":"T3419"},{"id":"R2638","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3418","obj":"T3417"},{"id":"R2639","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3419","obj":"T3414"},{"id":"R2640","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3420","obj":"T3419"},{"id":"R2641","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3420","obj":"T3421"},{"id":"R2642","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3420","obj":"T3422"},{"id":"R2643","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3423","obj":"T3422"},{"id":"R2644","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3424","obj":"T3414"},{"id":"R2645","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3426","obj":"T3427"},{"id":"R2646","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3427","obj":"T3401"},{"id":"R2647","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3427","obj":"T3425"},{"id":"R2648","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3431","obj":"T3432"},{"id":"R2649","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3433","obj":"T3432"},{"id":"R2650","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3434","obj":"T3429"},{"id":"R2651","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3434","obj":"T3430"},{"id":"R2652","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3434","obj":"T3431"},{"id":"R2653","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3434","obj":"T3433"},{"id":"R2654","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3435","obj":"T3436"},{"id":"R2655","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3436","obj":"T3427"},{"id":"R2656","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3436","obj":"T3428"},{"id":"R2657","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3436","obj":"T3429"},{"id":"R2658","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3436","obj":"T3437"},{"id":"R2659","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3439","obj":"T3436"},{"id":"R2660","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3439","obj":"T3438"},{"id":"R2661","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3439","obj":"T3440"},{"id":"R2662","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3441","obj":"T3440"},{"id":"R2663","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3441","obj":"T3443"},{"id":"R2664","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3443","obj":"T3442"},{"id":"R2665","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3444","obj":"T3440"},{"id":"R2666","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3446","obj":"T3445"},{"id":"R2667","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3448","obj":"T3449"},{"id":"R2668","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3448","obj":"T3451"},{"id":"R2669","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3450","obj":"T3449"},{"id":"R2670","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3451","obj":"T3445"},{"id":"R2671","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3451","obj":"T3447"},{"id":"R2672","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3451","obj":"T3452"},{"id":"R2673","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3455","obj":"T3452"},{"id":"R2674","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3455","obj":"T3453"},{"id":"R2675","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3455","obj":"T3454"},{"id":"R2676","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3455","obj":"T3456"},{"id":"R2677","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3459","obj":"T3456"},{"id":"R2678","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3459","obj":"T3457"},{"id":"R2679","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3459","obj":"T3458"},{"id":"R2680","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3459","obj":"T3460"},{"id":"R2681","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3461","obj":"T3460"},{"id":"R2682","pred":"arg3Of","subj":"T3462","obj":"T3460"},{"id":"R2683","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3466","obj":"T3465"},{"id":"R2684","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3466","obj":"T3467"},{"id":"R2685","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3466","obj":"T3472"},{"id":"R2686","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3470","obj":"T3467"},{"id":"R2687","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3470","obj":"T3468"},{"id":"R2688","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3470","obj":"T3469"},{"id":"R2689","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3472","obj":"T3463"},{"id":"R2690","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3472","obj":"T3464"},{"id":"R2691","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3472","obj":"T3471"},{"id":"R2692","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3472","obj":"T3473"},{"id":"R2693","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3472","obj":"T3485"},{"id":"R2694","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3472","obj":"T3495"},{"id":"R2695","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3473","obj":"T3483"},{"id":"R2696","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3475","obj":"T3473"},{"id":"R2697","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3475","obj":"T3474"},{"id":"R2698","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3475","obj":"T3476"},{"id":"R2699","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3475","obj":"T3478"},{"id":"R2700","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3477","obj":"T3476"},{"id":"R2701","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3478","obj":"T3479"},{"id":"R2702","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3482","obj":"T3479"},{"id":"R2703","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3482","obj":"T3480"},{"id":"R2704","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3482","obj":"T3481"},{"id":"R2705","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3485","obj":"T3494"},{"id":"R2706","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3488","obj":"T3485"},{"id":"R2707","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3488","obj":"T3486"},{"id":"R2708","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3488","obj":"T3487"},{"id":"R2709","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3488","obj":"T3490"},{"id":"R2710","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3490","obj":"T3489"},{"id":"R2711","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3491","obj":"T3492"},{"id":"R2712","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3492","obj":"T3490"},{"id":"R2713","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3493","obj":"T3492"},{"id":"R2714","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3494","obj":"T3483"},{"id":"R2715","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3494","obj":"T3484"},{"id":"R2716","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3495","obj":"T3494"},{"id":"R2717","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3497","obj":"T3495"},{"id":"R2718","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3497","obj":"T3496"},{"id":"R2719","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3497","obj":"T3498"},{"id":"R2720","pred":"arg2Of","subj":"T3501","obj":"T3498"},{"id":"R2721","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3501","obj":"T3499"},{"id":"R2722","pred":"arg1Of","subj":"T3501","obj":"T3500"}],"namespaces":[{"prefix":"_base","uri":"http://kmcs.nii.ac.jp/enju/"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
bionlp-st-ge-2016-coref
{"project":"bionlp-st-ge-2016-coref","denotations":[{"id":"T3502","span":{"begin":2371,"end":2386},"obj":"Anaphor"},{"id":"T3503","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"Antecedent"},{"id":"T3504","span":{"begin":2920,"end":2941},"obj":"Anaphor"},{"id":"T3505","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"Antecedent"},{"id":"T3506","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"Antecedent"}],"relations":[{"id":"R2723","pred":"boundBy","subj":"T3502","obj":"T3503"},{"id":"R2724","pred":"boundBy","subj":"T3504","obj":"T3505"},{"id":"R2725","pred":"boundBy","subj":"T3504","obj":"T3506"}],"namespaces":[{"prefix":"_base","uri":"https://bionlp.dbcls.jp/ontology/ge.owl#"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
bionlp-st-ge-2016-spacy-parsed
{"project":"bionlp-st-ge-2016-spacy-parsed","denotations":[{"id":"T3574","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3575","span":{"begin":6,"end":9},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3576","span":{"begin":10,"end":14},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3577","span":{"begin":15,"end":20},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3578","span":{"begin":21,"end":23},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3579","span":{"begin":24,"end":31},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3580","span":{"begin":32,"end":38},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3581","span":{"begin":39,"end":42},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3582","span":{"begin":43,"end":54},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3583","span":{"begin":55,"end":57},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3584","span":{"begin":58,"end":61},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3585","span":{"begin":62,"end":67},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3586","span":{"begin":68,"end":77},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3587","span":{"begin":78,"end":83},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3588","span":{"begin":84,"end":86},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3589","span":{"begin":87,"end":92},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3590","span":{"begin":93,"end":96},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3591","span":{"begin":97,"end":112},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3592","span":{"begin":113,"end":115},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3593","span":{"begin":116,"end":119},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3594","span":{"begin":120,"end":125},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3595","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3596","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3597","span":{"begin":144,"end":147},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3598","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3599","span":{"begin":153,"end":154},"obj":","},{"id":"T3600","span":{"begin":155,"end":157},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T3601","span":{"begin":158,"end":166},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3602","span":{"begin":167,"end":175},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3603","span":{"begin":176,"end":190},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3604","span":{"begin":191,"end":195},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3605","span":{"begin":195,"end":198},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3606","span":{"begin":199,"end":204},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3607","span":{"begin":205,"end":208},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3608","span":{"begin":208,"end":209},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3609","span":{"begin":210,"end":211},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3610","span":{"begin":212,"end":217},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3611","span":{"begin":218,"end":222},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3612","span":{"begin":223,"end":231},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3613","span":{"begin":232,"end":235},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3614","span":{"begin":236,"end":238},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3615","span":{"begin":239,"end":243},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3616","span":{"begin":244,"end":247},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3617","span":{"begin":248,"end":258},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3618","span":{"begin":259,"end":264},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3619","span":{"begin":265,"end":267},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3620","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3621","span":{"begin":278,"end":285},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3622","span":{"begin":286,"end":293},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3623","span":{"begin":294,"end":295},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3624","span":{"begin":295,"end":298},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3625","span":{"begin":298,"end":299},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3626","span":{"begin":299,"end":300},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3627","span":{"begin":301,"end":308},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3628","span":{"begin":309,"end":313},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3629","span":{"begin":314,"end":318},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3630","span":{"begin":319,"end":324},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3631","span":{"begin":325,"end":327},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3632","span":{"begin":328,"end":335},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3633","span":{"begin":336,"end":339},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3634","span":{"begin":340,"end":341},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3635","span":{"begin":342,"end":346},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3636","span":{"begin":347,"end":351},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3637","span":{"begin":352,"end":356},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3638","span":{"begin":357,"end":359},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3639","span":{"begin":360,"end":363},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3640","span":{"begin":364,"end":369},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3641","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3642","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3643","span":{"begin":387,"end":391},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3644","span":{"begin":392,"end":405},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3645","span":{"begin":406,"end":407},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3646","span":{"begin":407,"end":415},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3647","span":{"begin":416,"end":418},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3648","span":{"begin":419,"end":422},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3649","span":{"begin":422,"end":423},"obj":","},{"id":"T3650","span":{"begin":424,"end":428},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3651","span":{"begin":428,"end":429},"obj":":"},{"id":"T3652","span":{"begin":430,"end":436},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3653","span":{"begin":437,"end":439},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3654","span":{"begin":440,"end":443},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3655","span":{"begin":443,"end":444},"obj":","},{"id":"T3656","span":{"begin":445,"end":449},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3657","span":{"begin":449,"end":450},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3658","span":{"begin":450,"end":451},"obj":","},{"id":"T3659","span":{"begin":452,"end":455},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3660","span":{"begin":456,"end":459},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3661","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3662","span":{"begin":466,"end":467},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3663","span":{"begin":467,"end":473},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3664","span":{"begin":474,"end":477},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3665","span":{"begin":478,"end":487},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3666","span":{"begin":488,"end":494},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3667","span":{"begin":494,"end":495},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3668","span":{"begin":495,"end":496},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3669","span":{"begin":497,"end":504},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3670","span":{"begin":505,"end":509},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3671","span":{"begin":510,"end":513},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3672","span":{"begin":514,"end":521},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3673","span":{"begin":522,"end":527},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3674","span":{"begin":528,"end":533},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3675","span":{"begin":534,"end":537},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3676","span":{"begin":538,"end":542},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3677","span":{"begin":543,"end":553},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3678","span":{"begin":554,"end":557},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3679","span":{"begin":558,"end":560},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3680","span":{"begin":561,"end":564},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3681","span":{"begin":565,"end":580},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3682","span":{"begin":581,"end":583},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3683","span":{"begin":584,"end":587},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3684","span":{"begin":588,"end":593},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3685","span":{"begin":593,"end":594},"obj":","},{"id":"T3686","span":{"begin":595,"end":600},"obj":"WDT"},{"id":"T3687","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3688","span":{"begin":611,"end":615},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3689","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3690","span":{"begin":621,"end":624},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3691","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3692","span":{"begin":631,"end":635},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3693","span":{"begin":636,"end":649},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3694","span":{"begin":650,"end":651},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3695","span":{"begin":651,"end":657},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3696","span":{"begin":658,"end":661},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3697","span":{"begin":661,"end":662},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3698","span":{"begin":662,"end":663},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3699","span":{"begin":664,"end":671},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3700","span":{"begin":672,"end":674},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3701","span":{"begin":675,"end":680},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3702","span":{"begin":681,"end":684},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3703","span":{"begin":684,"end":685},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3704","span":{"begin":686,"end":687},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3705","span":{"begin":688,"end":693},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3706","span":{"begin":694,"end":696},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3707","span":{"begin":697,"end":699},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3708","span":{"begin":700,"end":708},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3709","span":{"begin":709,"end":715},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3710","span":{"begin":716,"end":718},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3711","span":{"begin":719,"end":730},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3712","span":{"begin":731,"end":735},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3713","span":{"begin":736,"end":744},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3714","span":{"begin":745,"end":748},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3715","span":{"begin":749,"end":758},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3716","span":{"begin":759,"end":769},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3717","span":{"begin":770,"end":772},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3718","span":{"begin":773,"end":776},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3719","span":{"begin":777,"end":785},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3720","span":{"begin":786,"end":788},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3721","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3722","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3723","span":{"begin":804,"end":806},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3724","span":{"begin":807,"end":822},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3725","span":{"begin":823,"end":826},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3726","span":{"begin":827,"end":832},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3727","span":{"begin":832,"end":833},"obj":","},{"id":"T3728","span":{"begin":834,"end":835},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3729","span":{"begin":836,"end":846},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3730","span":{"begin":847,"end":849},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3731","span":{"begin":850,"end":855},"obj":"WDT"},{"id":"T3732","span":{"begin":856,"end":866},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3733","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3734","span":{"begin":872,"end":873},"obj":","},{"id":"T3735","span":{"begin":874,"end":876},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3736","span":{"begin":877,"end":880},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3737","span":{"begin":881,"end":884},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3738","span":{"begin":885,"end":890},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3739","span":{"begin":891,"end":900},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3740","span":{"begin":901,"end":905},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3741","span":{"begin":906,"end":913},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3742","span":{"begin":914,"end":916},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3743","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3744","span":{"begin":922,"end":923},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3745","span":{"begin":923,"end":929},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3746","span":{"begin":930,"end":933},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3747","span":{"begin":933,"end":934},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3748","span":{"begin":934,"end":935},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3749","span":{"begin":936,"end":938},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3750","span":{"begin":939,"end":950},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3751","span":{"begin":951,"end":958},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3752","span":{"begin":959,"end":962},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3753","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3754","span":{"begin":968,"end":970},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3755","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3756","span":{"begin":977,"end":985},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3757","span":{"begin":986,"end":988},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3758","span":{"begin":989,"end":992},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3759","span":{"begin":993,"end":998},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3760","span":{"begin":999,"end":1007},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3761","span":{"begin":1008,"end":1012},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3762","span":{"begin":1013,"end":1023},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3763","span":{"begin":1024,"end":1026},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3764","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3765","span":{"begin":1033,"end":1043},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3766","span":{"begin":1044,"end":1046},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3767","span":{"begin":1047,"end":1050},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3768","span":{"begin":1051,"end":1054},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3769","span":{"begin":1055,"end":1059},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3770","span":{"begin":1060,"end":1067},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3771","span":{"begin":1068,"end":1072},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3772","span":{"begin":1073,"end":1075},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3773","span":{"begin":1076,"end":1089},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3774","span":{"begin":1090,"end":1098},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3775","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3776","span":{"begin":1104,"end":1105},"obj":","},{"id":"T3777","span":{"begin":1106,"end":1108},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T3778","span":{"begin":1109,"end":1117},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3779","span":{"begin":1118,"end":1123},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3780","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1127},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3781","span":{"begin":1127,"end":1128},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3782","span":{"begin":1129,"end":1130},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3783","span":{"begin":1131,"end":1136},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3784","span":{"begin":1137,"end":1141},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3785","span":{"begin":1142,"end":1152},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3786","span":{"begin":1153,"end":1158},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3787","span":{"begin":1159,"end":1161},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3788","span":{"begin":1162,"end":1169},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3789","span":{"begin":1170,"end":1179},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3790","span":{"begin":1180,"end":1182},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3791","span":{"begin":1183,"end":1185},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3792","span":{"begin":1186,"end":1188},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3793","span":{"begin":1189,"end":1192},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3794","span":{"begin":1193,"end":1201},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3795","span":{"begin":1202,"end":1204},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3796","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3797","span":{"begin":1210,"end":1211},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3798","span":{"begin":1212,"end":1214},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3799","span":{"begin":1215,"end":1218},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3800","span":{"begin":1219,"end":1224},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3801","span":{"begin":1225,"end":1227},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3802","span":{"begin":1228,"end":1235},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3803","span":{"begin":1235,"end":1236},"obj":","},{"id":"T3804","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3805","span":{"begin":1243,"end":1252},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3806","span":{"begin":1253,"end":1256},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3807","span":{"begin":1257,"end":1268},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3808","span":{"begin":1269,"end":1271},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3809","span":{"begin":1272,"end":1275},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3810","span":{"begin":1276,"end":1281},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3811","span":{"begin":1282,"end":1285},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3812","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3813","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3814","span":{"begin":1300,"end":1310},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3815","span":{"begin":1311,"end":1314},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3816","span":{"begin":1315,"end":1319},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3817","span":{"begin":1320,"end":1323},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3818","span":{"begin":1324,"end":1330},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3819","span":{"begin":1331,"end":1333},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3820","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3821","span":{"begin":1340,"end":1350},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3822","span":{"begin":1350,"end":1351},"obj":","},{"id":"T3823","span":{"begin":1352,"end":1362},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3824","span":{"begin":1363,"end":1367},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3825","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3826","span":{"begin":1374,"end":1377},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3827","span":{"begin":1378,"end":1380},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T3828","span":{"begin":1381,"end":1384},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3829","span":{"begin":1385,"end":1388},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3830","span":{"begin":1389,"end":1399},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3831","span":{"begin":1400,"end":1402},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3832","span":{"begin":1403,"end":1409},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3833","span":{"begin":1410,"end":1421},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3834","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3835","span":{"begin":1428,"end":1438},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3836","span":{"begin":1439,"end":1441},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3837","span":{"begin":1442,"end":1445},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3838","span":{"begin":1446,"end":1451},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3839","span":{"begin":1452,"end":1453},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3840","span":{"begin":1453,"end":1459},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3841","span":{"begin":1460,"end":1462},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3842","span":{"begin":1462,"end":1463},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3843","span":{"begin":1463,"end":1464},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3844","span":{"begin":1465,"end":1475},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3845","span":{"begin":1475,"end":1476},"obj":","},{"id":"T3846","span":{"begin":1477,"end":1479},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3847","span":{"begin":1480,"end":1483},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3848","span":{"begin":1484,"end":1491},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3849","span":{"begin":1492,"end":1496},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3850","span":{"begin":1497,"end":1500},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3851","span":{"begin":1501,"end":1510},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3852","span":{"begin":1510,"end":1511},"obj":","},{"id":"T3853","span":{"begin":1512,"end":1515},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3854","span":{"begin":1516,"end":1527},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3855","span":{"begin":1528,"end":1534},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3856","span":{"begin":1535,"end":1539},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3857","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3858","span":{"begin":1546,"end":1549},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3859","span":{"begin":1550,"end":1559},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3860","span":{"begin":1560,"end":1566},"obj":"JJR"},{"id":"T3861","span":{"begin":1567,"end":1574},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3862","span":{"begin":1575,"end":1577},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3863","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1593},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3864","span":{"begin":1594,"end":1599},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3865","span":{"begin":1600,"end":1601},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3866","span":{"begin":1601,"end":1607},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3867","span":{"begin":1608,"end":1610},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3868","span":{"begin":1610,"end":1611},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3869","span":{"begin":1612,"end":1615},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3870","span":{"begin":1616,"end":1624},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3871","span":{"begin":1625,"end":1629},"obj":"RBR"},{"id":"T3872","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3873","span":{"begin":1636,"end":1643},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3874","span":{"begin":1644,"end":1648},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3875","span":{"begin":1649,"end":1662},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3876","span":{"begin":1663,"end":1664},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3877","span":{"begin":1664,"end":1671},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3878","span":{"begin":1672,"end":1674},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3879","span":{"begin":1675,"end":1678},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3880","span":{"begin":1679,"end":1681},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3881","span":{"begin":1681,"end":1682},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3882","span":{"begin":1682,"end":1683},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3883","span":{"begin":1684,"end":1688},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3884","span":{"begin":1688,"end":1689},"obj":","},{"id":"T3885","span":{"begin":1690,"end":1693},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3886","span":{"begin":1694,"end":1705},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3887","span":{"begin":1706,"end":1708},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3888","span":{"begin":1709,"end":1712},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3889","span":{"begin":1713,"end":1718},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3890","span":{"begin":1719,"end":1728},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T3891","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3892","span":{"begin":1735,"end":1743},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3893","span":{"begin":1744,"end":1748},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3894","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3895","span":{"begin":1755,"end":1758},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3896","span":{"begin":1759,"end":1763},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3897","span":{"begin":1764,"end":1769},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3898","span":{"begin":1770,"end":1772},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3899","span":{"begin":1773,"end":1780},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3900","span":{"begin":1780,"end":1781},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3901","span":{"begin":1782,"end":1785},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3902","span":{"begin":1786,"end":1791},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3903","span":{"begin":1792,"end":1806},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3904","span":{"begin":1807,"end":1809},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3905","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3906","span":{"begin":1818,"end":1823},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3907","span":{"begin":1824,"end":1831},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3908","span":{"begin":1832,"end":1834},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3909","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3910","span":{"begin":1841,"end":1844},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3911","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3912","span":{"begin":1851,"end":1854},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3913","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3914","span":{"begin":1860,"end":1865},"obj":"PRP$"},{"id":"T3915","span":{"begin":1866,"end":1874},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3916","span":{"begin":1875,"end":1877},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3917","span":{"begin":1878,"end":1885},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T3918","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3919","span":{"begin":1891,"end":1892},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3920","span":{"begin":1892,"end":1898},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3921","span":{"begin":1899,"end":1901},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3922","span":{"begin":1901,"end":1902},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3923","span":{"begin":1902,"end":1903},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3924","span":{"begin":1904,"end":1911},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3925","span":{"begin":1912,"end":1915},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3926","span":{"begin":1916,"end":1924},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3927","span":{"begin":1925,"end":1927},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3928","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3929","span":{"begin":1934,"end":1941},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3930","span":{"begin":1942,"end":1945},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3931","span":{"begin":1946,"end":1959},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3932","span":{"begin":1960,"end":1962},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3933","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1966},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3934","span":{"begin":1966,"end":1967},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3935","span":{"begin":1968,"end":1969},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3936","span":{"begin":1970,"end":1975},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3937","span":{"begin":1976,"end":1978},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3938","span":{"begin":1979,"end":1983},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3939","span":{"begin":1984,"end":1988},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3940","span":{"begin":1989,"end":1992},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3941","span":{"begin":1993,"end":1996},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3942","span":{"begin":1997,"end":2004},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3943","span":{"begin":2005,"end":2010},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3944","span":{"begin":2011,"end":2012},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3945","span":{"begin":2012,"end":2017},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3946","span":{"begin":2018,"end":2020},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3947","span":{"begin":2020,"end":2021},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3948","span":{"begin":2021,"end":2022},"obj":","},{"id":"T3949","span":{"begin":2023,"end":2026},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T3950","span":{"begin":2027,"end":2031},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3951","span":{"begin":2032,"end":2035},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3952","span":{"begin":2036,"end":2042},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3953","span":{"begin":2043,"end":2049},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T3954","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3955","span":{"begin":2056,"end":2066},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3956","span":{"begin":2066,"end":2067},"obj":","},{"id":"T3957","span":{"begin":2068,"end":2071},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3958","span":{"begin":2072,"end":2083},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3959","span":{"begin":2084,"end":2086},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3960","span":{"begin":2087,"end":2091},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3961","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2107},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3962","span":{"begin":2108,"end":2113},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3963","span":{"begin":2114,"end":2116},"obj":"VBZ"},{"id":"T3964","span":{"begin":2117,"end":2121},"obj":"RBS"},{"id":"T3965","span":{"begin":2122,"end":2128},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3966","span":{"begin":2129,"end":2132},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T3967","span":{"begin":2133,"end":2140},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3968","span":{"begin":2141,"end":2143},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T3969","span":{"begin":2144,"end":2151},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3970","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3971","span":{"begin":2156,"end":2157},"obj":"."},{"id":"T3972","span":{"begin":2158,"end":2163},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3973","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2167},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3974","span":{"begin":2167,"end":2168},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3975","span":{"begin":2169,"end":2170},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3976","span":{"begin":2171,"end":2176},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3977","span":{"begin":2177,"end":2181},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3978","span":{"begin":2182,"end":2186},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T3979","span":{"begin":2186,"end":2189},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3980","span":{"begin":2189,"end":2190},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3981","span":{"begin":2190,"end":2214},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3982","span":{"begin":2215,"end":2219},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3983","span":{"begin":2220,"end":2221},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T3984","span":{"begin":2222,"end":2223},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T3985","span":{"begin":2223,"end":2227},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3986","span":{"begin":2227,"end":2228},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T3987","span":{"begin":2228,"end":2229},"obj":":"},{"id":"T3988","span":{"begin":2229,"end":2238},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3989","span":{"begin":2239,"end":2246},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3990","span":{"begin":2246,"end":2247},"obj":","},{"id":"T3991","span":{"begin":2248,"end":2256},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T3992","span":{"begin":2257,"end":2261},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3993","span":{"begin":2262,"end":2266},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T3994","span":{"begin":2267,"end":2272},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T3995","span":{"begin":2273,"end":2275},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3996","span":{"begin":2276,"end":2283},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T3997","span":{"begin":2284,"end":2286},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T3998","span":{"begin":2287,"end":2290},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T3999","span":{"begin":2291,"end":2299},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4000","span":{"begin":2300,"end":2302},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4001","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4002","span":{"begin":2308,"end":2309},"obj":","},{"id":"T4003","span":{"begin":2310,"end":2314},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4004","span":{"begin":2315,"end":2323},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T4005","span":{"begin":2324,"end":2326},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4006","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4007","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4008","span":{"begin":2344,"end":2346},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4009","span":{"begin":2347,"end":2350},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4010","span":{"begin":2351,"end":2356},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4011","span":{"begin":2356,"end":2357},"obj":","},{"id":"T4012","span":{"begin":2358,"end":2365},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T4013","span":{"begin":2366,"end":2370},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4014","span":{"begin":2371,"end":2375},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4015","span":{"begin":2376,"end":2386},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4016","span":{"begin":2387,"end":2390},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T4017","span":{"begin":2391,"end":2394},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4018","span":{"begin":2395,"end":2404},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4019","span":{"begin":2405,"end":2407},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4020","span":{"begin":2408,"end":2411},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4021","span":{"begin":2412,"end":2420},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4022","span":{"begin":2421,"end":2423},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4023","span":{"begin":2424,"end":2432},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4024","span":{"begin":2433,"end":2435},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T4025","span":{"begin":2436,"end":2442},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4026","span":{"begin":2443,"end":2444},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4027","span":{"begin":2445,"end":2450},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4028","span":{"begin":2451,"end":2453},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T4029","span":{"begin":2454,"end":2458},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4030","span":{"begin":2459,"end":2464},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4031","span":{"begin":2465,"end":2466},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T4032","span":{"begin":2466,"end":2472},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4033","span":{"begin":2473,"end":2475},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T4034","span":{"begin":2475,"end":2476},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T4035","span":{"begin":2476,"end":2477},"obj":"."},{"id":"T4036","span":{"begin":2478,"end":2486},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4037","span":{"begin":2487,"end":2489},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T4038","span":{"begin":2490,"end":2493},"obj":"VBZ"},{"id":"T4039","span":{"begin":2494,"end":2498},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T4040","span":{"begin":2499,"end":2508},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T4041","span":{"begin":2509,"end":2513},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4042","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4043","span":{"begin":2520,"end":2523},"obj":"MD"},{"id":"T4044","span":{"begin":2524,"end":2530},"obj":"VB"},{"id":"T4045","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4046","span":{"begin":2537,"end":2539},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4047","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2543},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4048","span":{"begin":2543,"end":2544},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4049","span":{"begin":2545,"end":2546},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4050","span":{"begin":2547,"end":2552},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4051","span":{"begin":2553,"end":2554},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T4052","span":{"begin":2554,"end":2560},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4053","span":{"begin":2561,"end":2563},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T4054","span":{"begin":2564,"end":2567},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T4055","span":{"begin":2567,"end":2568},"obj":","},{"id":"T4056","span":{"begin":2569,"end":2573},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T4057","span":{"begin":2573,"end":2574},"obj":":"},{"id":"T4058","span":{"begin":2575,"end":2582},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4059","span":{"begin":2583,"end":2585},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T4060","span":{"begin":2586,"end":2589},"obj":"FW"},{"id":"T4061","span":{"begin":2589,"end":2590},"obj":","},{"id":"T4062","span":{"begin":2591,"end":2595},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T4063","span":{"begin":2595,"end":2596},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T4064","span":{"begin":2596,"end":2597},"obj":","},{"id":"T4065","span":{"begin":2598,"end":2600},"obj":"PRP"},{"id":"T4066","span":{"begin":2601,"end":2606},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T4067","span":{"begin":2607,"end":2611},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4068","span":{"begin":2612,"end":2614},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4069","span":{"begin":2615,"end":2625},"obj":"VBG"},{"id":"T4070","span":{"begin":2626,"end":2629},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4071","span":{"begin":2630,"end":2633},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T4072","span":{"begin":2634,"end":2637},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4073","span":{"begin":2638,"end":2643},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4074","span":{"begin":2644,"end":2648},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4075","span":{"begin":2649,"end":2652},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T4076","span":{"begin":2653,"end":2656},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4077","span":{"begin":2657,"end":2660},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4078","span":{"begin":2661,"end":2665},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4079","span":{"begin":2666,"end":2667},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T4080","span":{"begin":2667,"end":2671},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4081","span":{"begin":2672,"end":2675},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4082","span":{"begin":2676,"end":2681},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T4083","span":{"begin":2681,"end":2682},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T4084","span":{"begin":2682,"end":2683},"obj":"."},{"id":"T4085","span":{"begin":2684,"end":2686},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4086","span":{"begin":2687,"end":2691},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4087","span":{"begin":2691,"end":2692},"obj":","},{"id":"T4088","span":{"begin":2693,"end":2707},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4089","span":{"begin":2708,"end":2710},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4090","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4091","span":{"begin":2717,"end":2720},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T4092","span":{"begin":2721,"end":2723},"obj":"TO"},{"id":"T4093","span":{"begin":2724,"end":2733},"obj":"VBN"},{"id":"T4094","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4095","span":{"begin":2740,"end":2750},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4096","span":{"begin":2751,"end":2753},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4097","span":{"begin":2754,"end":2758},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4098","span":{"begin":2759,"end":2760},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4099","span":{"begin":2761,"end":2765},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4100","span":{"begin":2766,"end":2773},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4101","span":{"begin":2774,"end":2775},"obj":"-LRB-"},{"id":"T4102","span":{"begin":2775,"end":2781},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4103","span":{"begin":2782,"end":2784},"obj":"CD"},{"id":"T4104","span":{"begin":2784,"end":2785},"obj":"-RRB-"},{"id":"T4105","span":{"begin":2785,"end":2786},"obj":"."},{"id":"T4106","span":{"begin":2787,"end":2791},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4107","span":{"begin":2791,"end":2792},"obj":","},{"id":"T4108","span":{"begin":2793,"end":2796},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4109","span":{"begin":2797,"end":2808},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4110","span":{"begin":2809,"end":2811},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4111","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2827},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4112","span":{"begin":2828,"end":2831},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4113","span":{"begin":2832,"end":2837},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4114","span":{"begin":2838,"end":2842},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4115","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"VBD"},{"id":"T4116","span":{"begin":2852,"end":2854},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4117","span":{"begin":2855,"end":2858},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4118","span":{"begin":2859,"end":2867},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4119","span":{"begin":2868,"end":2870},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4120","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4121","span":{"begin":2877,"end":2885},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4122","span":{"begin":2886,"end":2890},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4123","span":{"begin":2891,"end":2895},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4124","span":{"begin":2896,"end":2903},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4125","span":{"begin":2904,"end":2908},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4126","span":{"begin":2909,"end":2912},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T4127","span":{"begin":2913,"end":2916},"obj":"RB"},{"id":"T4128","span":{"begin":2917,"end":2919},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4129","span":{"begin":2920,"end":2925},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4130","span":{"begin":2926,"end":2933},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4131","span":{"begin":2934,"end":2941},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4132","span":{"begin":2942,"end":2946},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4133","span":{"begin":2947,"end":2949},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4134","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4135","span":{"begin":2955,"end":2957},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T4136","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4137","span":{"begin":2964,"end":2966},"obj":"CC"},{"id":"T4138","span":{"begin":2967,"end":2969},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4139","span":{"begin":2970,"end":2973},"obj":"DT"},{"id":"T4140","span":{"begin":2974,"end":2982},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4141","span":{"begin":2983,"end":2985},"obj":"IN"},{"id":"T4142","span":{"begin":2986,"end":2991},"obj":"JJ"},{"id":"T4143","span":{"begin":2992,"end":2993},"obj":"NNP"},{"id":"T4144","span":{"begin":2994,"end":2998},"obj":"NN"},{"id":"T4145","span":{"begin":2999,"end":3004},"obj":"NNS"},{"id":"T4146","span":{"begin":3004,"end":3005},"obj":"."}],"relations":[{"id":"R2726","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3574","obj":"T3589"},{"id":"R2727","pred":"cc","subj":"T3575","obj":"T3574"},{"id":"R2728","pred":"amod","subj":"T3576","obj":"T3577"},{"id":"R2729","pred":"conj","subj":"T3577","obj":"T3574"},{"id":"R2730","pred":"prep","subj":"T3578","obj":"T3577"},{"id":"R2731","pred":"compound","subj":"T3579","obj":"T3580"},{"id":"R2732","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3580","obj":"T3578"},{"id":"R2733","pred":"det","subj":"T3581","obj":"T3582"},{"id":"R2734","pred":"appos","subj":"T3582","obj":"T3580"},{"id":"R2735","pred":"prep","subj":"T3583","obj":"T3582"},{"id":"R2736","pred":"compound","subj":"T3584","obj":"T3587"},{"id":"R2737","pred":"compound","subj":"T3585","obj":"T3586"},{"id":"R2738","pred":"compound","subj":"T3586","obj":"T3587"},{"id":"R2739","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3587","obj":"T3583"},{"id":"R2740","pred":"aux","subj":"T3588","obj":"T3589"},{"id":"R2741","pred":"ccomp","subj":"T3589","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2742","pred":"det","subj":"T3590","obj":"T3591"},{"id":"R2743","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3591","obj":"T3589"},{"id":"R2744","pred":"prep","subj":"T3592","obj":"T3591"},{"id":"R2745","pred":"amod","subj":"T3593","obj":"T3594"},{"id":"R2746","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3594","obj":"T3592"},{"id":"R2747","pred":"advcl","subj":"T3595","obj":"T3589"},{"id":"R2748","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3596","obj":"T3595"},{"id":"R2749","pred":"cc","subj":"T3597","obj":"T3596"},{"id":"R2750","pred":"conj","subj":"T3598","obj":"T3596"},{"id":"R2751","pred":"punct","subj":"T3599","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2752","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3600","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2753","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3601","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2754","pred":"amod","subj":"T3602","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2755","pred":"amod","subj":"T3603","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2756","pred":"nmod","subj":"T3604","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2757","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3605","obj":"T3604"},{"id":"R2758","pred":"amod","subj":"T3606","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2759","pred":"compound","subj":"T3607","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2760","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3608","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2761","pred":"compound","subj":"T3609","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2762","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3610","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2763","pred":"prep","subj":"T3611","obj":"T3610"},{"id":"R2764","pred":"amod","subj":"T3612","obj":"T3613"},{"id":"R2765","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3613","obj":"T3611"},{"id":"R2766","pred":"prep","subj":"T3614","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2767","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3615","obj":"T3614"},{"id":"R2768","pred":"cc","subj":"T3616","obj":"T3615"},{"id":"R2769","pred":"amod","subj":"T3617","obj":"T3618"},{"id":"R2770","pred":"conj","subj":"T3618","obj":"T3615"},{"id":"R2771","pred":"prep","subj":"T3619","obj":"T3618"},{"id":"R2772","pred":"compound","subj":"T3620","obj":"T3621"},{"id":"R2773","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3621","obj":"T3619"},{"id":"R2774","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3622","obj":"T3621"},{"id":"R2775","pred":"punct","subj":"T3623","obj":"T3624"},{"id":"R2776","pred":"appos","subj":"T3624","obj":"T3621"},{"id":"R2777","pred":"punct","subj":"T3625","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2778","pred":"punct","subj":"T3626","obj":"T3601"},{"id":"R2779","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3627","obj":"T3636"},{"id":"R2780","pred":"prep","subj":"T3628","obj":"T3627"},{"id":"R2781","pred":"amod","subj":"T3629","obj":"T3630"},{"id":"R2782","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3630","obj":"T3628"},{"id":"R2783","pred":"prep","subj":"T3631","obj":"T3630"},{"id":"R2784","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3632","obj":"T3631"},{"id":"R2785","pred":"prep","subj":"T3633","obj":"T3627"},{"id":"R2786","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3634","obj":"T3635"},{"id":"R2787","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3635","obj":"T3633"},{"id":"R2788","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3636","obj":"T3636"},{"id":"R2789","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3637","obj":"T3636"},{"id":"R2790","pred":"prep","subj":"T3638","obj":"T3637"},{"id":"R2791","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3639","obj":"T3640"},{"id":"R2792","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3640","obj":"T3638"},{"id":"R2793","pred":"acl","subj":"T3641","obj":"T3640"},{"id":"R2794","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3642","obj":"T3641"},{"id":"R2795","pred":"prep","subj":"T3643","obj":"T3641"},{"id":"R2796","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3644","obj":"T3643"},{"id":"R2797","pred":"punct","subj":"T3645","obj":"T3648"},{"id":"R2798","pred":"amod","subj":"T3646","obj":"T3648"},{"id":"R2799","pred":"nmod","subj":"T3647","obj":"T3648"},{"id":"R2800","pred":"appos","subj":"T3648","obj":"T3640"},{"id":"R2801","pred":"punct","subj":"T3649","obj":"T3648"},{"id":"R2802","pred":"npadvmod","subj":"T3650","obj":"T3648"},{"id":"R2803","pred":"punct","subj":"T3651","obj":"T3638"},{"id":"R2804","pred":"compound","subj":"T3652","obj":"T3654"},{"id":"R2805","pred":"compound","subj":"T3653","obj":"T3654"},{"id":"R2806","pred":"appos","subj":"T3654","obj":"T3637"},{"id":"R2807","pred":"punct","subj":"T3655","obj":"T3654"},{"id":"R2808","pred":"npadvmod","subj":"T3656","obj":"T3654"},{"id":"R2809","pred":"punct","subj":"T3657","obj":"T3637"},{"id":"R2810","pred":"punct","subj":"T3658","obj":"T3636"},{"id":"R2811","pred":"cc","subj":"T3659","obj":"T3636"},{"id":"R2812","pred":"neg","subj":"T3660","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2813","pred":"nmod","subj":"T3661","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2814","pred":"punct","subj":"T3662","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2815","pred":"compound","subj":"T3663","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2816","pred":"conj","subj":"T3664","obj":"T3636"},{"id":"R2817","pred":"amod","subj":"T3665","obj":"T3666"},{"id":"R2818","pred":"appos","subj":"T3666","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2819","pred":"punct","subj":"T3667","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2820","pred":"punct","subj":"T3668","obj":"T3664"},{"id":"R2821","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3669","obj":"T3678"},{"id":"R2822","pred":"prep","subj":"T3670","obj":"T3669"},{"id":"R2823","pred":"amod","subj":"T3671","obj":"T3673"},{"id":"R2824","pred":"compound","subj":"T3672","obj":"T3673"},{"id":"R2825","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3673","obj":"T3670"},{"id":"R2826","pred":"prep","subj":"T3674","obj":"T3673"},{"id":"R2827","pred":"det","subj":"T3675","obj":"T3677"},{"id":"R2828","pred":"amod","subj":"T3676","obj":"T3677"},{"id":"R2829","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3677","obj":"T3674"},{"id":"R2830","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3678","obj":"T3678"},{"id":"R2831","pred":"prep","subj":"T3679","obj":"T3678"},{"id":"R2832","pred":"det","subj":"T3680","obj":"T3681"},{"id":"R2833","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3681","obj":"T3679"},{"id":"R2834","pred":"prep","subj":"T3682","obj":"T3681"},{"id":"R2835","pred":"amod","subj":"T3683","obj":"T3684"},{"id":"R2836","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3684","obj":"T3682"},{"id":"R2837","pred":"punct","subj":"T3685","obj":"T3681"},{"id":"R2838","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3686","obj":"T3687"},{"id":"R2839","pred":"relcl","subj":"T3687","obj":"T3681"},{"id":"R2840","pred":"det","subj":"T3688","obj":"T3689"},{"id":"R2841","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3689","obj":"T3687"},{"id":"R2842","pred":"cc","subj":"T3690","obj":"T3689"},{"id":"R2843","pred":"conj","subj":"T3691","obj":"T3689"},{"id":"R2844","pred":"prep","subj":"T3692","obj":"T3687"},{"id":"R2845","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3693","obj":"T3692"},{"id":"R2846","pred":"punct","subj":"T3694","obj":"T3695"},{"id":"R2847","pred":"appos","subj":"T3695","obj":"T3693"},{"id":"R2848","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3696","obj":"T3695"},{"id":"R2849","pred":"punct","subj":"T3697","obj":"T3695"},{"id":"R2850","pred":"punct","subj":"T3698","obj":"T3678"},{"id":"R2851","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3699","obj":"T3722"},{"id":"R2852","pred":"prep","subj":"T3700","obj":"T3699"},{"id":"R2853","pred":"amod","subj":"T3701","obj":"T3705"},{"id":"R2854","pred":"compound","subj":"T3702","obj":"T3705"},{"id":"R2855","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3703","obj":"T3705"},{"id":"R2856","pred":"compound","subj":"T3704","obj":"T3705"},{"id":"R2857","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3705","obj":"T3700"},{"id":"R2858","pred":"prep","subj":"T3706","obj":"T3699"},{"id":"R2859","pred":"det","subj":"T3707","obj":"T3709"},{"id":"R2860","pred":"amod","subj":"T3708","obj":"T3709"},{"id":"R2861","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3709","obj":"T3706"},{"id":"R2862","pred":"prep","subj":"T3710","obj":"T3709"},{"id":"R2863","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3711","obj":"T3710"},{"id":"R2864","pred":"prep","subj":"T3712","obj":"T3709"},{"id":"R2865","pred":"amod","subj":"T3713","obj":"T3716"},{"id":"R2866","pred":"cc","subj":"T3714","obj":"T3713"},{"id":"R2867","pred":"conj","subj":"T3715","obj":"T3713"},{"id":"R2868","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3716","obj":"T3712"},{"id":"R2869","pred":"prep","subj":"T3717","obj":"T3699"},{"id":"R2870","pred":"det","subj":"T3718","obj":"T3719"},{"id":"R2871","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3719","obj":"T3717"},{"id":"R2872","pred":"prep","subj":"T3720","obj":"T3719"},{"id":"R2873","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3721","obj":"T3720"},{"id":"R2874","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3722","obj":"T3722"},{"id":"R2875","pred":"prep","subj":"T3723","obj":"T3722"},{"id":"R2876","pred":"amod","subj":"T3724","obj":"T3726"},{"id":"R2877","pred":"amod","subj":"T3725","obj":"T3726"},{"id":"R2878","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3726","obj":"T3723"},{"id":"R2879","pred":"punct","subj":"T3727","obj":"T3722"},{"id":"R2880","pred":"det","subj":"T3728","obj":"T3729"},{"id":"R2881","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3729","obj":"T3736"},{"id":"R2882","pred":"prep","subj":"T3730","obj":"T3729"},{"id":"R2883","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3731","obj":"T3730"},{"id":"R2884","pred":"compound","subj":"T3732","obj":"T3733"},{"id":"R2885","pred":"appos","subj":"T3733","obj":"T3729"},{"id":"R2886","pred":"punct","subj":"T3734","obj":"T3736"},{"id":"R2887","pred":"mark","subj":"T3735","obj":"T3736"},{"id":"R2888","pred":"conj","subj":"T3736","obj":"T3722"},{"id":"R2889","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3737","obj":"T3738"},{"id":"R2890","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3738","obj":"T3736"},{"id":"R2891","pred":"acl","subj":"T3739","obj":"T3738"},{"id":"R2892","pred":"prep","subj":"T3740","obj":"T3739"},{"id":"R2893","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3741","obj":"T3740"},{"id":"R2894","pred":"prep","subj":"T3742","obj":"T3741"},{"id":"R2895","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3743","obj":"T3742"},{"id":"R2896","pred":"punct","subj":"T3744","obj":"T3745"},{"id":"R2897","pred":"appos","subj":"T3745","obj":"T3741"},{"id":"R2898","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3746","obj":"T3745"},{"id":"R2899","pred":"punct","subj":"T3747","obj":"T3736"},{"id":"R2900","pred":"punct","subj":"T3748","obj":"T3736"},{"id":"R2901","pred":"aux","subj":"T3749","obj":"T3750"},{"id":"R2902","pred":"advcl","subj":"T3750","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2903","pred":"mark","subj":"T3751","obj":"T3760"},{"id":"R2904","pred":"det","subj":"T3752","obj":"T3753"},{"id":"R2905","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3753","obj":"T3760"},{"id":"R2906","pred":"prep","subj":"T3754","obj":"T3753"},{"id":"R2907","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3755","obj":"T3754"},{"id":"R2908","pred":"acl","subj":"T3756","obj":"T3755"},{"id":"R2909","pred":"agent","subj":"T3757","obj":"T3756"},{"id":"R2910","pred":"amod","subj":"T3758","obj":"T3759"},{"id":"R2911","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3759","obj":"T3757"},{"id":"R2912","pred":"ccomp","subj":"T3760","obj":"T3750"},{"id":"R2913","pred":"prep","subj":"T3761","obj":"T3760"},{"id":"R2914","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3762","obj":"T3761"},{"id":"R2915","pred":"prep","subj":"T3763","obj":"T3762"},{"id":"R2916","pred":"compound","subj":"T3764","obj":"T3765"},{"id":"R2917","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3765","obj":"T3763"},{"id":"R2918","pred":"prep","subj":"T3766","obj":"T3765"},{"id":"R2919","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3767","obj":"T3766"},{"id":"R2920","pred":"cc","subj":"T3768","obj":"T3767"},{"id":"R2921","pred":"amod","subj":"T3769","obj":"T3770"},{"id":"R2922","pred":"compound","subj":"T3770","obj":"T3771"},{"id":"R2923","pred":"conj","subj":"T3771","obj":"T3765"},{"id":"R2924","pred":"cc","subj":"T3772","obj":"T3760"},{"id":"R2925","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3773","obj":"T3774"},{"id":"R2926","pred":"conj","subj":"T3774","obj":"T3760"},{"id":"R2927","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3775","obj":"T3774"},{"id":"R2928","pred":"punct","subj":"T3776","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2929","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3777","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2930","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3778","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2931","pred":"amod","subj":"T3779","obj":"T3783"},{"id":"R2932","pred":"compound","subj":"T3780","obj":"T3783"},{"id":"R2933","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3781","obj":"T3783"},{"id":"R2934","pred":"compound","subj":"T3782","obj":"T3783"},{"id":"R2935","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3783","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2936","pred":"prep","subj":"T3784","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2937","pred":"amod","subj":"T3785","obj":"T3786"},{"id":"R2938","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3786","obj":"T3784"},{"id":"R2939","pred":"prep","subj":"T3787","obj":"T3786"},{"id":"R2940","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3788","obj":"T3787"},{"id":"R2941","pred":"acl","subj":"T3789","obj":"T3788"},{"id":"R2942","pred":"agent","subj":"T3790","obj":"T3789"},{"id":"R2943","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3791","obj":"T3790"},{"id":"R2944","pred":"prep","subj":"T3792","obj":"T3789"},{"id":"R2945","pred":"det","subj":"T3793","obj":"T3794"},{"id":"R2946","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3794","obj":"T3792"},{"id":"R2947","pred":"prep","subj":"T3795","obj":"T3794"},{"id":"R2948","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3796","obj":"T3795"},{"id":"R2949","pred":"punct","subj":"T3797","obj":"T3778"},{"id":"R2950","pred":"prep","subj":"T3798","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2951","pred":"amod","subj":"T3799","obj":"T3800"},{"id":"R2952","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3800","obj":"T3798"},{"id":"R2953","pred":"prep","subj":"T3801","obj":"T3800"},{"id":"R2954","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3802","obj":"T3801"},{"id":"R2955","pred":"punct","subj":"T3803","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2956","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3804","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2957","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3805","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2958","pred":"det","subj":"T3806","obj":"T3807"},{"id":"R2959","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3807","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2960","pred":"prep","subj":"T3808","obj":"T3807"},{"id":"R2961","pred":"amod","subj":"T3809","obj":"T3810"},{"id":"R2962","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3810","obj":"T3808"},{"id":"R2963","pred":"cc","subj":"T3811","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2964","pred":"conj","subj":"T3812","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2965","pred":"amod","subj":"T3813","obj":"T3814"},{"id":"R2966","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3814","obj":"T3812"},{"id":"R2967","pred":"cc","subj":"T3815","obj":"T3812"},{"id":"R2968","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3816","obj":"T3818"},{"id":"R2969","pred":"amod","subj":"T3817","obj":"T3818"},{"id":"R2970","pred":"conj","subj":"T3818","obj":"T3812"},{"id":"R2971","pred":"prep","subj":"T3819","obj":"T3818"},{"id":"R2972","pred":"compound","subj":"T3820","obj":"T3821"},{"id":"R2973","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3821","obj":"T3819"},{"id":"R2974","pred":"punct","subj":"T3822","obj":"T3812"},{"id":"R2975","pred":"advcl","subj":"T3823","obj":"T3812"},{"id":"R2976","pred":"mark","subj":"T3824","obj":"T3828"},{"id":"R2977","pred":"amod","subj":"T3825","obj":"T3827"},{"id":"R2978","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3826","obj":"T3827"},{"id":"R2979","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3827","obj":"T3828"},{"id":"R2980","pred":"ccomp","subj":"T3828","obj":"T3823"},{"id":"R2981","pred":"neg","subj":"T3829","obj":"T3828"},{"id":"R2982","pred":"acomp","subj":"T3830","obj":"T3828"},{"id":"R2983","pred":"aux","subj":"T3831","obj":"T3832"},{"id":"R2984","pred":"xcomp","subj":"T3832","obj":"T3830"},{"id":"R2985","pred":"amod","subj":"T3833","obj":"T3835"},{"id":"R2986","pred":"compound","subj":"T3834","obj":"T3835"},{"id":"R2987","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3835","obj":"T3832"},{"id":"R2988","pred":"prep","subj":"T3836","obj":"T3835"},{"id":"R2989","pred":"amod","subj":"T3837","obj":"T3838"},{"id":"R2990","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3838","obj":"T3836"},{"id":"R2991","pred":"punct","subj":"T3839","obj":"T3840"},{"id":"R2992","pred":"appos","subj":"T3840","obj":"T3835"},{"id":"R2993","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3841","obj":"T3840"},{"id":"R2994","pred":"punct","subj":"T3842","obj":"T3840"},{"id":"R2995","pred":"punct","subj":"T3843","obj":"T3805"},{"id":"R2996","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3844","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R2997","pred":"punct","subj":"T3845","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R2998","pred":"mark","subj":"T3846","obj":"T3851"},{"id":"R2999","pred":"det","subj":"T3847","obj":"T3849"},{"id":"R3000","pred":"compound","subj":"T3848","obj":"T3849"},{"id":"R3001","pred":"nsubjpass","subj":"T3849","obj":"T3851"},{"id":"R3002","pred":"auxpass","subj":"T3850","obj":"T3851"},{"id":"R3003","pred":"advcl","subj":"T3851","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3004","pred":"punct","subj":"T3852","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3005","pred":"amod","subj":"T3853","obj":"T3854"},{"id":"R3006","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3854","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3007","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3855","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3008","pred":"prep","subj":"T3856","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3009","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3857","obj":"T3856"},{"id":"R3010","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3858","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3011","pred":"conj","subj":"T3859","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3012","pred":"amod","subj":"T3860","obj":"T3861"},{"id":"R3013","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3861","obj":"T3859"},{"id":"R3014","pred":"prep","subj":"T3862","obj":"T3861"},{"id":"R3015","pred":"amod","subj":"T3863","obj":"T3864"},{"id":"R3016","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3864","obj":"T3862"},{"id":"R3017","pred":"punct","subj":"T3865","obj":"T3866"},{"id":"R3018","pred":"appos","subj":"T3866","obj":"T3861"},{"id":"R3019","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3867","obj":"T3866"},{"id":"R3020","pred":"punct","subj":"T3868","obj":"T3866"},{"id":"R3021","pred":"cc","subj":"T3869","obj":"T3859"},{"id":"R3022","pred":"conj","subj":"T3870","obj":"T3859"},{"id":"R3023","pred":"amod","subj":"T3871","obj":"T3873"},{"id":"R3024","pred":"amod","subj":"T3872","obj":"T3873"},{"id":"R3025","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3873","obj":"T3870"},{"id":"R3026","pred":"prep","subj":"T3874","obj":"T3873"},{"id":"R3027","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3875","obj":"T3874"},{"id":"R3028","pred":"punct","subj":"T3876","obj":"T3878"},{"id":"R3029","pred":"compound","subj":"T3877","obj":"T3878"},{"id":"R3030","pred":"appos","subj":"T3878","obj":"T3873"},{"id":"R3031","pred":"cc","subj":"T3879","obj":"T3878"},{"id":"R3032","pred":"conj","subj":"T3880","obj":"T3878"},{"id":"R3033","pred":"punct","subj":"T3881","obj":"T3878"},{"id":"R3034","pred":"punct","subj":"T3882","obj":"T3855"},{"id":"R3035","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3883","obj":"T3892"},{"id":"R3036","pred":"punct","subj":"T3884","obj":"T3892"},{"id":"R3037","pred":"det","subj":"T3885","obj":"T3886"},{"id":"R3038","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3886","obj":"T3892"},{"id":"R3039","pred":"prep","subj":"T3887","obj":"T3886"},{"id":"R3040","pred":"amod","subj":"T3888","obj":"T3889"},{"id":"R3041","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3889","obj":"T3887"},{"id":"R3042","pred":"acl","subj":"T3890","obj":"T3889"},{"id":"R3043","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3891","obj":"T3890"},{"id":"R3044","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3892","obj":"T3892"},{"id":"R3045","pred":"preconj","subj":"T3893","obj":"T3894"},{"id":"R3046","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3894","obj":"T3892"},{"id":"R3047","pred":"cc","subj":"T3895","obj":"T3894"},{"id":"R3048","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3962","obj":"T3959"},{"id":"R3049","pred":"amod","subj":"T3896","obj":"T3897"},{"id":"R3050","pred":"conj","subj":"T3963","obj":"T3953"},{"id":"R3051","pred":"conj","subj":"T3897","obj":"T3894"},{"id":"R3052","pred":"prep","subj":"T3898","obj":"T3897"},{"id":"R3053","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3964","obj":"T3965"},{"id":"R3054","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3899","obj":"T3898"},{"id":"R3055","pred":"punct","subj":"T3900","obj":"T3892"},{"id":"R3056","pred":"acomp","subj":"T3965","obj":"T3963"},{"id":"R3057","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3901","obj":"T3902"},{"id":"R3058","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3902","obj":"T3913"},{"id":"R3059","pred":"acl","subj":"T3903","obj":"T3902"},{"id":"R3060","pred":"neg","subj":"T3966","obj":"T3967"},{"id":"R3061","pred":"aux","subj":"T3904","obj":"T3905"},{"id":"R3062","pred":"advcl","subj":"T3905","obj":"T3903"},{"id":"R3063","pred":"amod","subj":"T3906","obj":"T3907"},{"id":"R3064","pred":"acomp","subj":"T3967","obj":"T3963"},{"id":"R3065","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3907","obj":"T3905"},{"id":"R3066","pred":"prep","subj":"T3908","obj":"T3907"},{"id":"R3067","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3909","obj":"T3908"},{"id":"R3068","pred":"prep","subj":"T3968","obj":"T3967"},{"id":"R3069","pred":"cc","subj":"T3910","obj":"T3909"},{"id":"R3070","pred":"conj","subj":"T3911","obj":"T3909"},{"id":"R3071","pred":"amod","subj":"T3969","obj":"T3970"},{"id":"R3072","pred":"cc","subj":"T3912","obj":"T3903"},{"id":"R3073","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3913","obj":"T3913"},{"id":"R3074","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3970","obj":"T3968"},{"id":"R3075","pred":"punct","subj":"T3971","obj":"T3953"},{"id":"R3076","pred":"poss","subj":"T3914","obj":"T3915"},{"id":"R3077","pred":"amod","subj":"T3972","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3078","pred":"compound","subj":"T3973","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3079","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3915","obj":"T3913"},{"id":"R3080","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3974","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3081","pred":"compound","subj":"T3975","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3082","pred":"aux","subj":"T3916","obj":"T3917"},{"id":"R3083","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3976","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3084","pred":"prep","subj":"T3977","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3085","pred":"acl","subj":"T3917","obj":"T3915"},{"id":"R3086","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3918","obj":"T3917"},{"id":"R3087","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3978","obj":"T3977"},{"id":"R3088","pred":"punct","subj":"T3919","obj":"T3921"},{"id":"R3089","pred":"compound","subj":"T3920","obj":"T3921"},{"id":"R3090","pred":"appos","subj":"T3921","obj":"T3918"},{"id":"R3091","pred":"punct","subj":"T3922","obj":"T3921"},{"id":"R3092","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3979","obj":"T3978"},{"id":"R3093","pred":"punct","subj":"T3923","obj":"T3913"},{"id":"R3094","pred":"mark","subj":"T3924","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3095","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3980","obj":"T3989"},{"id":"R3096","pred":"det","subj":"T3925","obj":"T3926"},{"id":"R3097","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3926","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3098","pred":"prep","subj":"T3927","obj":"T3926"},{"id":"R3099","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3928","obj":"T3927"},{"id":"R3100","pred":"compound","subj":"T3981","obj":"T3982"},{"id":"R3101","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T3929","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3102","pred":"det","subj":"T3930","obj":"T3931"},{"id":"R3103","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3931","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3104","pred":"npadvmod","subj":"T3982","obj":"T3988"},{"id":"R3105","pred":"prep","subj":"T3932","obj":"T3931"},{"id":"R3106","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3933","obj":"T3936"},{"id":"R3107","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3934","obj":"T3936"},{"id":"R3108","pred":"nummod","subj":"T3983","obj":"T3982"},{"id":"R3109","pred":"compound","subj":"T3935","obj":"T3936"},{"id":"R3110","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3936","obj":"T3932"},{"id":"R3111","pred":"punct","subj":"T3984","obj":"T3985"},{"id":"R3112","pred":"prep","subj":"T3937","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3113","pred":"preconj","subj":"T3938","obj":"T3939"},{"id":"R3114","pred":"amod","subj":"T3939","obj":"T3943"},{"id":"R3115","pred":"cc","subj":"T3940","obj":"T3939"},{"id":"R3116","pred":"appos","subj":"T3985","obj":"T3982"},{"id":"R3117","pred":"conj","subj":"T3941","obj":"T3939"},{"id":"R3118","pred":"compound","subj":"T3942","obj":"T3943"},{"id":"R3119","pred":"punct","subj":"T3986","obj":"T3985"},{"id":"R3120","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3943","obj":"T3937"},{"id":"R3121","pred":"punct","subj":"T3944","obj":"T3946"},{"id":"R3122","pred":"compound","subj":"T3945","obj":"T3946"},{"id":"R3123","pred":"punct","subj":"T3987","obj":"T3988"},{"id":"R3124","pred":"appos","subj":"T3946","obj":"T3943"},{"id":"R3125","pred":"amod","subj":"T3988","obj":"T3989"},{"id":"R3126","pred":"conj","subj":"T3989","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3127","pred":"punct","subj":"T3947","obj":"T3946"},{"id":"R3128","pred":"punct","subj":"T3948","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3129","pred":"punct","subj":"T3990","obj":"T3989"},{"id":"R3130","pred":"cc","subj":"T3949","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3131","pred":"advmod","subj":"T3950","obj":"T3953"},{"id":"R3132","pred":"det","subj":"T3951","obj":"T3952"},{"id":"R3133","pred":"acl","subj":"T3991","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3134","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3952","obj":"T3953"},{"id":"R3135","pred":"conj","subj":"T3953","obj":"T3929"},{"id":"R3136","pred":"amod","subj":"T3954","obj":"T3955"},{"id":"R3137","pred":"dobj","subj":"T3955","obj":"T3953"},{"id":"R3138","pred":"punct","subj":"T3956","obj":"T3953"},{"id":"R3139","pred":"prep","subj":"T3992","obj":"T3991"},{"id":"R3140","pred":"det","subj":"T3957","obj":"T3958"},{"id":"R3141","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T3958","obj":"T3963"},{"id":"R3142","pred":"amod","subj":"T3993","obj":"T3994"},{"id":"R3143","pred":"prep","subj":"T3959","obj":"T3958"},{"id":"R3144","pred":"amod","subj":"T3960","obj":"T3962"},{"id":"R3145","pred":"amod","subj":"T3961","obj":"T3962"},{"id":"R3146","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3994","obj":"T3992"},{"id":"R3147","pred":"prep","subj":"T3995","obj":"T3994"},{"id":"R3148","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3996","obj":"T3995"},{"id":"R3149","pred":"prep","subj":"T3997","obj":"T3991"},{"id":"R3150","pred":"det","subj":"T3998","obj":"T3999"},{"id":"R3151","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4090","obj":"T4089"},{"id":"R3152","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T4091","obj":"T4091"},{"id":"R3153","pred":"pobj","subj":"T3999","obj":"T3997"},{"id":"R3154","pred":"prep","subj":"T4092","obj":"T4091"},{"id":"R3155","pred":"amod","subj":"T4093","obj":"T4095"},{"id":"R3156","pred":"amod","subj":"T4094","obj":"T4095"},{"id":"R3157","pred":"prep","subj":"T4000","obj":"T3999"},{"id":"R3158","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4095","obj":"T4092"},{"id":"R3159","pred":"prep","subj":"T4096","obj":"T4095"},{"id":"R3160","pred":"det","subj":"T4097","obj":"T4100"},{"id":"R3161","pred":"compound","subj":"T4098","obj":"T4099"},{"id":"R3162","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4001","obj":"T4000"},{"id":"R3163","pred":"compound","subj":"T4099","obj":"T4100"},{"id":"R3164","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4100","obj":"T4096"},{"id":"R3165","pred":"punct","subj":"T4002","obj":"T3976"},{"id":"R3166","pred":"punct","subj":"T4101","obj":"T4102"},{"id":"R3167","pred":"advmod","subj":"T4003","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3168","pred":"appos","subj":"T4102","obj":"T4100"},{"id":"R3169","pred":"nummod","subj":"T4103","obj":"T4102"},{"id":"R3170","pred":"punct","subj":"T4104","obj":"T4102"},{"id":"R3171","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T4004","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3172","pred":"punct","subj":"T4105","obj":"T4091"},{"id":"R3173","pred":"advmod","subj":"T4106","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3174","pred":"punct","subj":"T4107","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3175","pred":"prep","subj":"T4005","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3176","pred":"det","subj":"T4108","obj":"T4109"},{"id":"R3177","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T4109","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3178","pred":"prep","subj":"T4110","obj":"T4109"},{"id":"R3179","pred":"compound","subj":"T4006","obj":"T4007"},{"id":"R3180","pred":"amod","subj":"T4111","obj":"T4113"},{"id":"R3181","pred":"amod","subj":"T4112","obj":"T4113"},{"id":"R3182","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4113","obj":"T4110"},{"id":"R3183","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4007","obj":"T4005"},{"id":"R3184","pred":"advmod","subj":"T4114","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3185","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T4115","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3186","pred":"prep","subj":"T4116","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3187","pred":"det","subj":"T4117","obj":"T4118"},{"id":"R3188","pred":"prep","subj":"T4008","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3189","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4118","obj":"T4116"},{"id":"R3190","pred":"prep","subj":"T4119","obj":"T4118"},{"id":"R3191","pred":"amod","subj":"T4009","obj":"T4010"},{"id":"R3192","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4120","obj":"T4119"},{"id":"R3193","pred":"advmod","subj":"T4121","obj":"T4122"},{"id":"R3194","pred":"prep","subj":"T4122","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3195","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4010","obj":"T4008"},{"id":"R3196","pred":"amod","subj":"T4123","obj":"T4125"},{"id":"R3197","pred":"compound","subj":"T4124","obj":"T4125"},{"id":"R3198","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4125","obj":"T4122"},{"id":"R3199","pred":"punct","subj":"T4011","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3200","pred":"cc","subj":"T4126","obj":"T4125"},{"id":"R3201","pred":"neg","subj":"T4127","obj":"T4128"},{"id":"R3202","pred":"advcl","subj":"T4012","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3203","pred":"prep","subj":"T4128","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3204","pred":"amod","subj":"T4129","obj":"T4131"},{"id":"R3205","pred":"mark","subj":"T4013","obj":"T4016"},{"id":"R3206","pred":"amod","subj":"T4130","obj":"T4131"},{"id":"R3207","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4131","obj":"T4128"},{"id":"R3208","pred":"amod","subj":"T4132","obj":"T4133"},{"id":"R3209","pred":"prep","subj":"T4133","obj":"T4131"},{"id":"R3210","pred":"det","subj":"T4014","obj":"T4015"},{"id":"R3211","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4134","obj":"T4133"},{"id":"R3212","pred":"cc","subj":"T4135","obj":"T4134"},{"id":"R3213","pred":"conj","subj":"T4136","obj":"T4134"},{"id":"R3214","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T4015","obj":"T4016"},{"id":"R3215","pred":"cc","subj":"T4137","obj":"T4128"},{"id":"R3216","pred":"conj","subj":"T4138","obj":"T4128"},{"id":"R3217","pred":"det","subj":"T4139","obj":"T4140"},{"id":"R3218","pred":"ccomp","subj":"T4016","obj":"T4012"},{"id":"R3219","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4140","obj":"T4138"},{"id":"R3220","pred":"prep","subj":"T4141","obj":"T4140"},{"id":"R3221","pred":"neg","subj":"T4017","obj":"T4018"},{"id":"R3222","pred":"amod","subj":"T4142","obj":"T4145"},{"id":"R3223","pred":"compound","subj":"T4143","obj":"T4145"},{"id":"R3224","pred":"compound","subj":"T4144","obj":"T4145"},{"id":"R3225","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4145","obj":"T4141"},{"id":"R3226","pred":"acomp","subj":"T4018","obj":"T4016"},{"id":"R3227","pred":"punct","subj":"T4146","obj":"T4115"},{"id":"R3228","pred":"prep","subj":"T4019","obj":"T4018"},{"id":"R3229","pred":"det","subj":"T4020","obj":"T4021"},{"id":"R3230","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4021","obj":"T4019"},{"id":"R3231","pred":"prep","subj":"T4022","obj":"T4021"},{"id":"R3232","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4023","obj":"T4022"},{"id":"R3233","pred":"cc","subj":"T4024","obj":"T4023"},{"id":"R3234","pred":"compound","subj":"T4025","obj":"T4027"},{"id":"R3235","pred":"compound","subj":"T4026","obj":"T4027"},{"id":"R3236","pred":"conj","subj":"T4027","obj":"T4023"},{"id":"R3237","pred":"cc","subj":"T4028","obj":"T4027"},{"id":"R3238","pred":"compound","subj":"T4029","obj":"T4030"},{"id":"R3239","pred":"conj","subj":"T4030","obj":"T4027"},{"id":"R3240","pred":"punct","subj":"T4031","obj":"T4032"},{"id":"R3241","pred":"appos","subj":"T4032","obj":"T4021"},{"id":"R3242","pred":"nummod","subj":"T4033","obj":"T4032"},{"id":"R3243","pred":"punct","subj":"T4034","obj":"T4032"},{"id":"R3244","pred":"punct","subj":"T4035","obj":"T4004"},{"id":"R3245","pred":"mark","subj":"T4036","obj":"T4040"},{"id":"R3246","pred":"nsubjpass","subj":"T4037","obj":"T4040"},{"id":"R3247","pred":"aux","subj":"T4038","obj":"T4040"},{"id":"R3248","pred":"auxpass","subj":"T4039","obj":"T4040"},{"id":"R3249","pred":"advcl","subj":"T4040","obj":"T4066"},{"id":"R3250","pred":"mark","subj":"T4041","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3251","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T4042","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3252","pred":"aux","subj":"T4043","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3253","pred":"ccomp","subj":"T4044","obj":"T4040"},{"id":"R3254","pred":"dobj","subj":"T4045","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3255","pred":"prep","subj":"T4046","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3256","pred":"nmod","subj":"T4047","obj":"T4050"},{"id":"R3257","pred":"nmod","subj":"T4048","obj":"T4050"},{"id":"R3258","pred":"compound","subj":"T4049","obj":"T4050"},{"id":"R3259","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4050","obj":"T4046"},{"id":"R3260","pred":"punct","subj":"T4051","obj":"T4054"},{"id":"R3261","pred":"compound","subj":"T4052","obj":"T4054"},{"id":"R3262","pred":"nmod","subj":"T4053","obj":"T4054"},{"id":"R3263","pred":"parataxis","subj":"T4054","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3264","pred":"punct","subj":"T4055","obj":"T4054"},{"id":"R3265","pred":"npadvmod","subj":"T4056","obj":"T4054"},{"id":"R3266","pred":"punct","subj":"T4057","obj":"T4044"},{"id":"R3267","pred":"compound","subj":"T4058","obj":"T4060"},{"id":"R3268","pred":"compound","subj":"T4059","obj":"T4060"},{"id":"R3269","pred":"oprd","subj":"T4060","obj":"T4040"},{"id":"R3270","pred":"punct","subj":"T4061","obj":"T4060"},{"id":"R3271","pred":"appos","subj":"T4062","obj":"T4060"},{"id":"R3272","pred":"punct","subj":"T4063","obj":"T4060"},{"id":"R3273","pred":"punct","subj":"T4064","obj":"T4066"},{"id":"R3274","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T4065","obj":"T4066"},{"id":"R3275","pred":"ROOT","subj":"T4066","obj":"T4066"},{"id":"R3276","pred":"mark","subj":"T4067","obj":"T4075"},{"id":"R3277","pred":"prep","subj":"T4068","obj":"T4075"},{"id":"R3278","pred":"pcomp","subj":"T4069","obj":"T4068"},{"id":"R3279","pred":"nmod","subj":"T4070","obj":"T4073"},{"id":"R3280","pred":"cc","subj":"T4071","obj":"T4070"},{"id":"R3281","pred":"conj","subj":"T4072","obj":"T4070"},{"id":"R3282","pred":"dobj","subj":"T4073","obj":"T4069"},{"id":"R3283","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T4074","obj":"T4075"},{"id":"R3284","pred":"ccomp","subj":"T4075","obj":"T4066"},{"id":"R3285","pred":"neg","subj":"T4076","obj":"T4075"},{"id":"R3286","pred":"det","subj":"T4077","obj":"T4078"},{"id":"R3287","pred":"attr","subj":"T4078","obj":"T4075"},{"id":"R3288","pred":"punct","subj":"T4079","obj":"T4082"},{"id":"R3289","pred":"nsubjpass","subj":"T4080","obj":"T4082"},{"id":"R3290","pred":"neg","subj":"T4081","obj":"T4082"},{"id":"R3291","pred":"conj","subj":"T4082","obj":"T4075"},{"id":"R3292","pred":"punct","subj":"T4083","obj":"T4082"},{"id":"R3293","pred":"punct","subj":"T4084","obj":"T4066"},{"id":"R3294","pred":"prep","subj":"T4085","obj":"T4091"},{"id":"R3295","pred":"pobj","subj":"T4086","obj":"T4085"},{"id":"R3297","pred":"punct","subj":"T4087","obj":"T4091"},{"id":"R3299","pred":"nsubj","subj":"T4088","obj":"T4091"},{"id":"R3301","pred":"prep","subj":"T4089","obj":"T4088"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
GO-BP
{"project":"GO-BP","denotations":[{"id":"T4162","span":{"begin":43,"end":54},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032502"},{"id":"T4163","span":{"begin":1257,"end":1268},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032502"},{"id":"T4164","span":{"begin":1694,"end":1705},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032502"},{"id":"T4165","span":{"begin":2072,"end":2083},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032502"},{"id":"T4166","span":{"begin":2797,"end":2808},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032502"},{"id":"T4167","span":{"begin":176,"end":179},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0006283"},{"id":"T4168","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1043},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032653"},{"id":"T4169","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1438},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032653"},{"id":"T4170","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2066},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032653"},{"id":"T4171","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2750},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032653"},{"id":"T4172","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1043},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032613"},{"id":"T4173","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1438},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032613"},{"id":"T4174","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2066},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032613"},{"id":"T4175","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2750},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0032613"},{"id":"T4176","span":{"begin":1786,"end":1806},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0030154"},{"id":"T4177","span":{"begin":2436,"end":2442},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0007613"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
GO-MF
{"project":"GO-MF","denotations":[{"id":"T4178","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4179","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4180","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4181","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4182","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4183","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4184","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4185","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4186","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4187","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4188","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005143"},{"id":"T4189","span":{"begin":78,"end":83},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4190","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4191","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4192","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4193","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4194","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4195","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4196","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4197","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4198","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1583},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4199","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4200","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4201","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4202","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4203","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2097},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4204","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4205","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4206","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4207","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2817},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005141"},{"id":"T4208","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005136"},{"id":"T4209","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005136"},{"id":"T4210","span":{"begin":759,"end":769},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0003823"},{"id":"T4211","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005134"},{"id":"T4212","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005134"},{"id":"T4213","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005134"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
GO-CC
{"project":"GO-CC","denotations":[{"id":"T4214","span":{"begin":120,"end":125},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4215","span":{"begin":212,"end":217},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4216","span":{"begin":364,"end":369},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4217","span":{"begin":588,"end":593},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4218","span":{"begin":688,"end":693},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4219","span":{"begin":827,"end":832},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4220","span":{"begin":885,"end":890},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4221","span":{"begin":993,"end":998},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4222","span":{"begin":1131,"end":1136},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4223","span":{"begin":1276,"end":1281},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4224","span":{"begin":1446,"end":1451},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4225","span":{"begin":1594,"end":1599},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4226","span":{"begin":1713,"end":1718},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4227","span":{"begin":1786,"end":1791},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4228","span":{"begin":1970,"end":1975},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4229","span":{"begin":2108,"end":2113},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4230","span":{"begin":2171,"end":2176},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4231","span":{"begin":2351,"end":2356},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4232","span":{"begin":2445,"end":2450},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4233","span":{"begin":2459,"end":2464},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4234","span":{"begin":2547,"end":2552},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4235","span":{"begin":2638,"end":2643},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4236","span":{"begin":2832,"end":2837},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4237","span":{"begin":2994,"end":2998},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005623"},{"id":"T4238","span":{"begin":176,"end":179},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0042101"},{"id":"T4239","span":{"begin":700,"end":703},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0005680"},{"id":"T4240","span":{"begin":759,"end":769},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0019815"},{"id":"T4241","span":{"begin":759,"end":769},"obj":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/GO_0042571"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
sentences
{"project":"sentences","denotations":[{"id":"T2963","span":{"begin":0,"end":83},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2964","span":{"begin":84,"end":300},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2965","span":{"begin":301,"end":496},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2966","span":{"begin":497,"end":663},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2967","span":{"begin":664,"end":935},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2968","span":{"begin":936,"end":1211},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2969","span":{"begin":1212,"end":1464},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2970","span":{"begin":1465,"end":1683},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2971","span":{"begin":1684,"end":1781},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2972","span":{"begin":1782,"end":1903},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2973","span":{"begin":1904,"end":2157},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2974","span":{"begin":2158,"end":2477},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2975","span":{"begin":2478,"end":2683},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2976","span":{"begin":2684,"end":2786},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T2977","span":{"begin":2787,"end":3005},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T31","span":{"begin":0,"end":83},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T32","span":{"begin":84,"end":300},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T33","span":{"begin":301,"end":496},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T34","span":{"begin":497,"end":663},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T35","span":{"begin":664,"end":935},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T36","span":{"begin":936,"end":1211},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T37","span":{"begin":1212,"end":1464},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T38","span":{"begin":1465,"end":1683},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T39","span":{"begin":1684,"end":1781},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T40","span":{"begin":1782,"end":1903},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T41","span":{"begin":1904,"end":2157},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T42","span":{"begin":2158,"end":2477},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T43","span":{"begin":2478,"end":2683},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T44","span":{"begin":2684,"end":2786},"obj":"Sentence"},{"id":"T45","span":{"begin":2787,"end":3005},"obj":"Sentence"}],"namespaces":[{"prefix":"_base","uri":"http://pubannotation.org/ontology/tao.owl#"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
events-check-again
{"project":"events-check-again","denotations":[{"id":"T4448","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4449","span":{"begin":68,"end":77},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4450","span":{"begin":78,"end":83},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4451","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4452","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4453","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4454","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4455","span":{"begin":205,"end":208},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4456","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4457","span":{"begin":295,"end":298},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4458","span":{"begin":352,"end":356},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4459","span":{"begin":352,"end":356},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4460","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4461","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4462","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4463","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4464","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4465","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4466","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4467","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4468","span":{"begin":681,"end":684},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4469","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4470","span":{"begin":754,"end":758},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4471","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4472","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4473","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4474","span":{"begin":807,"end":812},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4475","span":{"begin":813,"end":822},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4476","span":{"begin":856,"end":866},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4477","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4478","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4479","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4480","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4481","span":{"begin":977,"end":985},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4482","span":{"begin":999,"end":1007},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4483","span":{"begin":1013,"end":1023},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4484","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4485","span":{"begin":1033,"end":1043},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4486","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4487","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1127},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4488","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4489","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4490","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4491","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4492","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4493","span":{"begin":1300,"end":1310},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4494","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4495","span":{"begin":1340,"end":1350},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4496","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4497","span":{"begin":1403,"end":1409},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4498","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4499","span":{"begin":1428,"end":1438},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4500","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4501","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1583},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4502","span":{"begin":1584,"end":1593},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4503","span":{"begin":1616,"end":1624},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4504","span":{"begin":1625,"end":1629},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4505","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4506","span":{"begin":1719,"end":1728},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4507","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4508","span":{"begin":1735,"end":1743},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4509","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4510","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4511","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4512","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4513","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4514","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4515","span":{"begin":1878,"end":1885},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4516","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4517","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4518","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1966},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4519","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4520","span":{"begin":2056,"end":2066},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4521","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2097},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4522","span":{"begin":2098,"end":2107},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4523","span":{"begin":2144,"end":2151},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4524","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4525","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2167},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4526","span":{"begin":2190,"end":2221},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4527","span":{"begin":2223,"end":2227},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4528","span":{"begin":2229,"end":2238},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4529","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4530","span":{"begin":2315,"end":2323},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4531","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4532","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4533","span":{"begin":2395,"end":2404},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4534","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4535","span":{"begin":2524,"end":2530},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4536","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4537","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2543},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4538","span":{"begin":2693,"end":2707},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4539","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4540","span":{"begin":2724,"end":2733},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4541","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4542","span":{"begin":2740,"end":2750},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4543","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2817},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4544","span":{"begin":2818,"end":2827},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4545","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4546","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4547","span":{"begin":2843,"end":2851},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4548","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4549","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4550","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"Protein"}],"relations":[{"id":"R3405","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4450","obj":"T4449"},{"id":"R3410","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4453","obj":"T4452"},{"id":"R3415","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4454","obj":"T4451"},{"id":"R3418","pred":"equivalentTo","subj":"T4457","obj":"T4456"},{"id":"R3423","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4460","obj":"T4458"},{"id":"R3429","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4461","obj":"T4459"},{"id":"R3431","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4462","obj":"T4461"},{"id":"R3432","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4463","obj":"T4460"},{"id":"R3433","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4466","obj":"T4465"},{"id":"R3434","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4467","obj":"T4464"},{"id":"R3435","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4526","obj":"T4528"},{"id":"R3436","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4471","obj":"T4473"},{"id":"R3437","pred":"equivalentTo","subj":"T4527","obj":"T4526"},{"id":"R3438","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4529","obj":"T4530"},{"id":"R3439","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4531","obj":"T4532"},{"id":"R3440","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4471","obj":"T4472"},{"id":"R3441","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4532","obj":"T4530"},{"id":"R3442","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4532","obj":"T4533"},{"id":"R3443","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4534","obj":"T4535"},{"id":"R3444","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4474","obj":"T4475"},{"id":"R3445","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4536","obj":"T4535"},{"id":"R3446","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4538","obj":"T4540"},{"id":"R3447","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4539","obj":"T4538"},{"id":"R3448","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4541","obj":"T4542"},{"id":"R3449","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4475","obj":"T4473"},{"id":"R3450","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4542","obj":"T4540"},{"id":"R3451","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4543","obj":"T4544"},{"id":"R3452","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4544","obj":"T4546"},{"id":"R3453","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4544","obj":"T4545"},{"id":"R3454","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4544","obj":"T4547"},{"id":"R3455","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4476","obj":"T4472"},{"id":"R3456","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4477","obj":"T4476"},{"id":"R3457","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4548","obj":"T4546"},{"id":"R3458","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4549","obj":"T4545"},{"id":"R3459","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4479","obj":"T4482"},{"id":"R3460","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4550","obj":"T4547"},{"id":"R3461","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4480","obj":"T4479"},{"id":"R3462","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4480","obj":"T4481"},{"id":"R3463","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4483","obj":"T4482"},{"id":"R3464","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4484","obj":"T4485"},{"id":"R3465","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4485","obj":"T4483"},{"id":"R3466","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4489","obj":"T4490"},{"id":"R3468","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4489","obj":"T4491"},{"id":"R3469","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4492","obj":"T4493"},{"id":"R3471","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4493","obj":"T4490"},{"id":"R3472","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4494","obj":"T4495"},{"id":"R3474","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4495","obj":"T4491"},{"id":"R3476","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4496","obj":"T4497"},{"id":"R3479","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4498","obj":"T4499"},{"id":"R3480","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4499","obj":"T4497"},{"id":"R3483","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4501","obj":"T4502"},{"id":"R3486","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4503","obj":"T4504"},{"id":"R3490","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4505","obj":"T4503"},{"id":"R3493","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4506","obj":"T4508"},{"id":"R3497","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4507","obj":"T4506"},{"id":"R3501","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4509","obj":"T4508"},{"id":"R3503","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4512","obj":"T4510"},{"id":"R3506","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4513","obj":"T4511"},{"id":"R3509","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4515","obj":"T4514"},{"id":"R3512","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4516","obj":"T4515"},{"id":"R3513","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4519","obj":"T4520"},{"id":"R3517","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4521","obj":"T4522"},{"id":"R3519","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4524","obj":"T4523"}],"attributes":[{"id":"M54","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T4482","obj":"true"},{"id":"M55","pred":"Negation","subj":"T4497","obj":"true"},{"id":"M56","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T4497","obj":"true"},{"id":"M57","pred":"Negation","subj":"T4533","obj":"true"},{"id":"M60","pred":"Negation","subj":"T4547","obj":"true"},{"id":"M58","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T4535","obj":"true"},{"id":"M53","pred":"Negation","subj":"T4460","obj":"true"},{"id":"M59","pred":"Negation","subj":"T4545","obj":"true"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
bionlp-st-ge-2016-reference-tees
{"project":"bionlp-st-ge-2016-reference-tees","denotations":[{"id":"T4551","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4552","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4553","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4554","span":{"begin":205,"end":209},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4555","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4556","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4557","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4558","span":{"begin":360,"end":363},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4559","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4560","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4561","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4562","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4563","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4564","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4565","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4566","span":{"begin":681,"end":685},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4567","span":{"begin":736,"end":744},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4568","span":{"begin":749,"end":769},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4569","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4570","span":{"begin":807,"end":812},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4571","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4572","span":{"begin":719,"end":730},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4573","span":{"begin":813,"end":822},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4574","span":{"begin":856,"end":866},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4575","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4576","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4577","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1128},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4578","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4579","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4580","span":{"begin":977,"end":985},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4581","span":{"begin":999,"end":1007},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4582","span":{"begin":1033,"end":1043},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4583","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4584","span":{"begin":1013,"end":1023},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4585","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4586","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4587","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4588","span":{"begin":1300,"end":1310},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4589","span":{"begin":1340,"end":1350},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4590","span":{"begin":1428,"end":1438},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4591","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4592","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4593","span":{"begin":1403,"end":1409},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4594","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4595","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1643},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4596","span":{"begin":1616,"end":1624},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4597","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4598","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4599","span":{"begin":1719,"end":1728},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4600","span":{"begin":1735,"end":1743},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4601","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4602","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4603","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4604","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4605","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4606","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1967},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4607","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2168},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4608","span":{"begin":2215,"end":2221},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4609","span":{"begin":2223,"end":2227},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4610","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4611","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4612","span":{"begin":2228,"end":2238},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4613","span":{"begin":2228,"end":2238},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4614","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4615","span":{"begin":2315,"end":2323},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4616","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4617","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4618","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2544},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4619","span":{"begin":2524,"end":2530},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4620","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4621","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4622","span":{"begin":2693,"end":2707},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T4623","span":{"begin":2740,"end":2750},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T4624","span":{"begin":2724,"end":2733},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T4625","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4626","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T4627","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"Protein"}],"relations":[{"id":"R3467","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4552","obj":"T4556"},{"id":"R3470","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4553","obj":"T4557"},{"id":"R3473","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4558","obj":"T4560"},{"id":"R3475","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4559","obj":"T4561"},{"id":"R3477","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4562","obj":"T4564"},{"id":"R3478","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4563","obj":"T4565"},{"id":"R3481","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4568","obj":"T4572"},{"id":"R3482","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4569","obj":"T4572"},{"id":"R3484","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4570","obj":"T4573"},{"id":"R3485","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4571","obj":"T4574"},{"id":"R3487","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4575","obj":"T4579"},{"id":"R3488","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4575","obj":"T4580"},{"id":"R3489","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4576","obj":"T4582"},{"id":"R3491","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4579","obj":"T4581"},{"id":"R3492","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4580","obj":"T4583"},{"id":"R3494","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4582","obj":"T4584"},{"id":"R3495","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4585","obj":"T4588"},{"id":"R3496","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4586","obj":"T4589"},{"id":"R3498","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4587","obj":"T4590"},{"id":"R3499","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4588","obj":"T4591"},{"id":"R3500","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4589","obj":"T4592"},{"id":"R3502","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4590","obj":"T4593"},{"id":"R3504","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4595","obj":"T4596"},{"id":"R3505","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4597","obj":"T4599"},{"id":"R3507","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4598","obj":"T4600"},{"id":"R3508","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4599","obj":"T4600"},{"id":"R3510","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4601","obj":"T4603"},{"id":"R3511","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4602","obj":"T4604"},{"id":"R3514","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4608","obj":"T4612"},{"id":"R3515","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4609","obj":"T4613"},{"id":"R3516","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4611","obj":"T4614"},{"id":"R3518","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4614","obj":"T4615"},{"id":"R3520","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T4616","obj":"T4619"},{"id":"R3521","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4617","obj":"T4619"},{"id":"R3522","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4623","obj":"T4624"},{"id":"R3523","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4620","obj":"T4622"},{"id":"R3524","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T4621","obj":"T4623"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}
test2
{"project":"test2","denotations":[{"id":"T2765","span":{"begin":0,"end":5},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2766","span":{"begin":68,"end":77},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2767","span":{"begin":126,"end":137},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2768","span":{"begin":138,"end":143},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2769","span":{"begin":148,"end":153},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2770","span":{"begin":205,"end":208},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2771","span":{"begin":268,"end":277},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2772","span":{"begin":295,"end":298},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2773","span":{"begin":370,"end":380},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2774","span":{"begin":381,"end":386},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2775","span":{"begin":460,"end":465},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2776","span":{"begin":601,"end":610},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2777","span":{"begin":616,"end":620},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2778","span":{"begin":625,"end":630},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2779","span":{"begin":681,"end":684},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2780","span":{"begin":741,"end":744},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2781","span":{"begin":754,"end":758},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2782","span":{"begin":789,"end":794},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2783","span":{"begin":795,"end":803},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2784","span":{"begin":807,"end":812},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2785","span":{"begin":813,"end":822},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2786","span":{"begin":856,"end":866},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2787","span":{"begin":867,"end":872},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2788","span":{"begin":891,"end":900},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2789","span":{"begin":917,"end":921},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2790","span":{"begin":963,"end":967},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2791","span":{"begin":971,"end":976},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2792","span":{"begin":977,"end":985},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2793","span":{"begin":999,"end":1007},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2794","span":{"begin":1013,"end":1023},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2795","span":{"begin":1027,"end":1032},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2796","span":{"begin":1033,"end":1043},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2797","span":{"begin":1090,"end":1098},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2798","span":{"begin":1099,"end":1104},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2799","span":{"begin":1124,"end":1127},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2800","span":{"begin":1205,"end":1210},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2801","span":{"begin":1237,"end":1242},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2802","span":{"begin":1286,"end":1293},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2803","span":{"begin":1294,"end":1299},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2804","span":{"begin":1300,"end":1310},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2805","span":{"begin":1334,"end":1339},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2806","span":{"begin":1340,"end":1350},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2807","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1373},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2808","span":{"begin":1403,"end":1409},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2809","span":{"begin":1422,"end":1427},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2810","span":{"begin":1428,"end":1438},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2811","span":{"begin":1540,"end":1545},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2812","span":{"begin":1578,"end":1583},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2813","span":{"begin":1584,"end":1593},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2814","span":{"begin":1616,"end":1624},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2815","span":{"begin":1630,"end":1635},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2816","span":{"begin":1719,"end":1728},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2817","span":{"begin":1729,"end":1734},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2818","span":{"begin":1735,"end":1743},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2819","span":{"begin":1749,"end":1754},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2820","span":{"begin":1810,"end":1817},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2821","span":{"begin":1835,"end":1840},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2822","span":{"begin":1845,"end":1850},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2823","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2824","span":{"begin":1878,"end":1885},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2825","span":{"begin":1886,"end":1890},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2826","span":{"begin":1928,"end":1933},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2827","span":{"begin":1963,"end":1966},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2828","span":{"begin":2050,"end":2055},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2829","span":{"begin":2056,"end":2066},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2830","span":{"begin":2087,"end":2091},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2831","span":{"begin":2092,"end":2097},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2832","span":{"begin":2098,"end":2107},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2833","span":{"begin":2144,"end":2151},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2834","span":{"begin":2152,"end":2156},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2835","span":{"begin":2164,"end":2167},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2836","span":{"begin":2190,"end":2221},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2837","span":{"begin":2223,"end":2227},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2838","span":{"begin":2229,"end":2238},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2839","span":{"begin":2303,"end":2308},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2840","span":{"begin":2315,"end":2323},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2841","span":{"begin":2327,"end":2332},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2842","span":{"begin":2333,"end":2343},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2843","span":{"begin":2376,"end":2386},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2844","span":{"begin":2395,"end":2404},"obj":"Regulation"},{"id":"T2845","span":{"begin":2514,"end":2519},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2846","span":{"begin":2524,"end":2530},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2847","span":{"begin":2531,"end":2536},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2848","span":{"begin":2540,"end":2543},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2849","span":{"begin":2693,"end":2707},"obj":"Negative_regulation"},{"id":"T2850","span":{"begin":2711,"end":2716},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2851","span":{"begin":2717,"end":2720},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2852","span":{"begin":2724,"end":2733},"obj":"Positive_regulation"},{"id":"T2853","span":{"begin":2734,"end":2739},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2854","span":{"begin":2740,"end":2750},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2855","span":{"begin":2812,"end":2817},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2856","span":{"begin":2818,"end":2827},"obj":"Gene_expression"},{"id":"T2857","span":{"begin":2871,"end":2876},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2858","span":{"begin":2950,"end":2954},"obj":"Protein"},{"id":"T2859","span":{"begin":2958,"end":2963},"obj":"Protein"}],"relations":[{"id":"R2081","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2768","obj":"T2767"},{"id":"R2082","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2769","obj":"T2767"},{"id":"R2083","pred":"equivalentTo","subj":"T2772","obj":"T2771"},{"id":"R2084","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2774","obj":"T2773"},{"id":"R2085","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2775","obj":"T2773"},{"id":"R2086","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2777","obj":"T2776"},{"id":"R2087","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2778","obj":"T2776"},{"id":"R2088","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2782","obj":"T2783"},{"id":"R2089","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2784","obj":"T2785"},{"id":"R2090","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2785","obj":"T2783"},{"id":"R2091","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2786","obj":"T2783"},{"id":"R2092","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2787","obj":"T2786"},{"id":"R2093","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2789","obj":"T2788"},{"id":"R2094","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2790","obj":"T2793"},{"id":"R2095","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2791","obj":"T2792"},{"id":"R2096","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2792","obj":"T2790"},{"id":"R2097","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2795","obj":"T2796"},{"id":"R2098","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2796","obj":"T2794"},{"id":"R2099","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2798","obj":"T2797"},{"id":"R2100","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2801","obj":"T2802"},{"id":"R2101","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2803","obj":"T2804"},{"id":"R2102","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2804","obj":"T2802"},{"id":"R2103","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2805","obj":"T2806"},{"id":"R2104","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2806","obj":"T2802"},{"id":"R2105","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2807","obj":"T2808"},{"id":"R2106","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2809","obj":"T2810"},{"id":"R2107","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2810","obj":"T2808"},{"id":"R2108","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2812","obj":"T2813"},{"id":"R2109","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2815","obj":"T2814"},{"id":"R2110","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2816","obj":"T2818"},{"id":"R2111","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2817","obj":"T2816"},{"id":"R2112","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2819","obj":"T2818"},{"id":"R2113","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2821","obj":"T2820"},{"id":"R2114","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2822","obj":"T2820"},{"id":"R2115","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2824","obj":"T2823"},{"id":"R2116","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2825","obj":"T2824"},{"id":"R2117","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2828","obj":"T2829"},{"id":"R2118","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2831","obj":"T2832"},{"id":"R2119","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2832","obj":"T2830"},{"id":"R2120","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2834","obj":"T2833"},{"id":"R2121","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2836","obj":"T2838"},{"id":"R2122","pred":"equivalentTo","subj":"T2837","obj":"T2836"},{"id":"R2123","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2841","obj":"T2842"},{"id":"R2124","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2842","obj":"T2840"},{"id":"R2125","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2842","obj":"T2844"},{"id":"R2126","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2843","obj":"T2844"},{"id":"R2127","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2845","obj":"T2846"},{"id":"R2128","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2847","obj":"T2846"},{"id":"R2129","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2849","obj":"T2852"},{"id":"R2130","pred":"causeOf","subj":"T2849","obj":"T2851"},{"id":"R2131","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2850","obj":"T2849"},{"id":"R2132","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2852","obj":"T2851"},{"id":"R2133","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2853","obj":"T2854"},{"id":"R2134","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2854","obj":"T2852"},{"id":"R2135","pred":"themeOf","subj":"T2855","obj":"T2856"}],"attributes":[{"id":"M21","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2771","obj":"true"},{"id":"M26","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T2805","obj":"true"},{"id":"M27","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2811","obj":"true"},{"id":"M25","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2804","obj":"true"},{"id":"M23","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2787","obj":"true"},{"id":"M24","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T2787","obj":"true"},{"id":"M22","pred":"Speculation","subj":"T2780","obj":"true"},{"id":"M28","pred":"Negation","subj":"T2812","obj":"true"}],"text":"IL-12 and High Doses of Antigen Induce the Development of Th1 Cells Producing IL-10\nTo study the differentiation of Th1 cells coproducing IFN-γ and IL-10, we cultured purified TCR-transgenic DO11.10 naive CD4+ T cells with purified DCs as APCs and increasing doses of ovalbumin peptide 323-339 (OVA). Culture with high doses of antigen for 7 days gave rise to Th1 cells expressing IFN-γ upon restimulation (Constant et al., 1995; Hosken et al., 1995), but not IL-10 (Figure S1A available online). Culture with low antigen doses under the same conditions led to the differentiation of Th2 cells, which expressed both IL-4 and IL-10 upon restimulation (Figure S1A). Culture of naive CD4+ T cells in an APC-free system by stimulation with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 antibodies in the presence of IL-12 resulted in IFN-γ-producing Th1 cells, a proportion of which coproduced IL-10, as did Th2 cells resulting from culture in IL-4 (Figure S1B).\nTo investigate whether the lack of IL-10 produced by Th1 cells resulted from inhibition of IL-10 production by DCs and high antigen dose or alternatively required IL-12, we cultured naive CD4+ T cells with increasing doses of antigen presented by DC in the presence of IL-12. At low doses of antigen, IL-12 abrogated the development of Th2 cells and induced IFN-γ expression but only low levels of IL-10 expression, suggesting that IL-12 per se was not sufficient to induce significant IL-10 production in Th1 cells (Figure 1A). Strikingly, as the antigen dose was increased, Th1 populations driven with IL-12 now contained higher numbers of IL-10-producing cells (Figure 1A) and produced more IL-10 protein upon restimulation (Figures 1A and 1B). Thus, the development of Th1 cells producing IL-10 required both IL-12 and high doses of antigen. Th1 cells differentiated to produce large amounts of IL-10 and IFN-γ and lost their capacity to produce IL-2 (Figure 1B). Because the presence of IL-12 reduced the proliferation of CD4+ T cells at both high and low antigen doses (Table S1), and only the former showed IL-10 production, the development of high IL-10-producing cells is most likely not related to limited IL-2. Naive CD4+ T cells from DO11.10/recombination-activating gene 1 (Rag1)-deficient animals, cultured with high doses of antigen in the presence of IL-12, also resulted in IL-10 expression by Th1 cells, showing that this expression was not dependent on the presence of effector or memory T cells or Treg cells (Figure S2). Although it has been suggested that TGF-β can induce IL-10 in CD4+ T cells (Kitani et al., 2003; Schiott et al., 2000), we found that in developing Th1 and Th2 cells this was not the case (data not shown). In fact, neutralization of TGF-β led to increased IL-10 production by both T cell subsets (Figure S3). Thus, the development of IL-10-producing Th1 cells only depended on the presence of IL-12 together with high antigen dose and not on other soluble factors such as IL-2 or TGF-β or on the presence of other T cell types."}