PMC:1084246 / 16302-17255 JSONTXT

{"project":"biosemtest","denotations":[{"id":"T2124","span":{"begin":224,"end":232},"obj":"UMLS/C1552607"},{"id":"T2125","span":{"begin":117,"end":122},"obj":"UMLS/C1706074"},{"id":"T2126","span":{"begin":233,"end":244},"obj":"UMLS/C1705241"},{"id":"T2127","span":{"begin":117,"end":122},"obj":"UMLS/C1706073"},{"id":"T2128","span":{"begin":174,"end":178},"obj":"UMLS/C1292711"},{"id":"T2129","span":{"begin":47,"end":58},"obj":"UMLS/C0679207"},{"id":"T2130","span":{"begin":0,"end":7},"obj":"UMLS/C0560184"},{"id":"T2131","span":{"begin":69,"end":76},"obj":"UMLS/C0560184"},{"id":"T2132","span":{"begin":482,"end":489},"obj":"UMLS/C0560184"},{"id":"T2133","span":{"begin":233,"end":244},"obj":"UMLS/C1705242"},{"id":"T2134","span":{"begin":730,"end":745},"obj":"UMLS/C0205345"},{"id":"T2135","span":{"begin":0,"end":7},"obj":"UMLS/C0560187"},{"id":"T2136","span":{"begin":69,"end":76},"obj":"UMLS/C0560187"},{"id":"T2137","span":{"begin":482,"end":489},"obj":"UMLS/C0560187"},{"id":"T2138","span":{"begin":437,"end":447},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T2139","span":{"begin":615,"end":624},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T2140","span":{"begin":697,"end":706},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T2141","span":{"begin":117,"end":122},"obj":"UMLS/C0039224"},{"id":"T2142","span":{"begin":608,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C0457385"},{"id":"T2143","span":{"begin":608,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C1561503"},{"id":"T2144","span":{"begin":462,"end":471},"obj":"UMLS/C0376298"},{"id":"T2145","span":{"begin":353,"end":364},"obj":"UMLS/C0870705"},{"id":"T2146","span":{"begin":587,"end":598},"obj":"UMLS/C0870705"},{"id":"T2147","span":{"begin":150,"end":159},"obj":"UMLS/C0680240"},{"id":"T2148","span":{"begin":293,"end":301},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T2149","span":{"begin":394,"end":402},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T2150","span":{"begin":248,"end":255},"obj":"UMLS/C0441800"},{"id":"T2151","span":{"begin":403,"end":411},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T2152","span":{"begin":608,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C2348168"},{"id":"T2153","span":{"begin":263,"end":270},"obj":"UMLS/C0332306"},{"id":"T2154","span":{"begin":608,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C0565930"},{"id":"T2155","span":{"begin":566,"end":571},"obj":"UMLS/C0243095"},{"id":"T2156","span":{"begin":145,"end":149},"obj":"UMLS/C2700379"},{"id":"T2157","span":{"begin":758,"end":760},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T2158","span":{"begin":582,"end":586},"obj":"UMLS/C0439064"},{"id":"T2159","span":{"begin":525,"end":528},"obj":"UMLS/C0005341"},{"id":"T2160","span":{"begin":608,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C1705190"},{"id":"T2161","span":{"begin":575,"end":581},"obj":"UMLS/C0027552"},{"id":"T2162","span":{"begin":174,"end":178},"obj":"UMLS/C1148523"},{"id":"T2163","span":{"begin":673,"end":681},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"},{"id":"T2164","span":{"begin":0,"end":7},"obj":"UMLS/C0014653"},{"id":"T2165","span":{"begin":69,"end":76},"obj":"UMLS/C0014653"},{"id":"T2166","span":{"begin":482,"end":489},"obj":"UMLS/C0014653"},{"id":"T2167","span":{"begin":378,"end":386},"obj":"UMLS/C2700399"},{"id":"T2168","span":{"begin":174,"end":178},"obj":"UMLS/C1552020"},{"id":"T2169","span":{"begin":315,"end":321},"obj":"UMLS/C0221191"},{"id":"T2170","span":{"begin":145,"end":149},"obj":"UMLS/C0032854"},{"id":"T2171","span":{"begin":749,"end":757},"obj":"UMLS/C0231441"},{"id":"T2172","span":{"begin":535,"end":544},"obj":"UMLS/C0332147"},{"id":"T2173","span":{"begin":554,"end":562},"obj":"UMLS/C0332147"},{"id":"T2174","span":{"begin":374,"end":377},"obj":"UMLS/C1518422"},{"id":"T2175","span":{"begin":0,"end":7},"obj":"UMLS/C0205415"},{"id":"T2176","span":{"begin":69,"end":76},"obj":"UMLS/C0205415"},{"id":"T2177","span":{"begin":482,"end":489},"obj":"UMLS/C0205415"},{"id":"T2178","span":{"begin":47,"end":58},"obj":"UMLS/C1516048"},{"id":"T2179","span":{"begin":145,"end":149},"obj":"UMLS/C1561559"},{"id":"T2180","span":{"begin":145,"end":149},"obj":"UMLS/C1561558"},{"id":"T2181","span":{"begin":378,"end":386},"obj":"UMLS/C1552866"},{"id":"T2182","span":{"begin":582,"end":586},"obj":"UMLS/C0205172"},{"id":"T2183","span":{"begin":691,"end":696},"obj":"UMLS/C1705160"},{"id":"T2184","span":{"begin":452,"end":459},"obj":"UMLS/C0596012"},{"id":"T2185","span":{"begin":378,"end":386},"obj":"UMLS/C0332257"},{"id":"T2186","span":{"begin":550,"end":553},"obj":"UMLS/C0205447"},{"id":"T2187","span":{"begin":145,"end":149},"obj":"UMLS/C0542537"},{"id":"T2188","span":{"begin":16,"end":24},"obj":"UMLS/C0814225"},{"id":"T2189","span":{"begin":85,"end":93},"obj":"UMLS/C0814225"},{"id":"T2190","span":{"begin":498,"end":506},"obj":"UMLS/C0814225"},{"id":"T2191","span":{"begin":765,"end":773},"obj":"UMLS/C0814225"},{"id":"T2192","span":{"begin":47,"end":58},"obj":"UMLS/C1261322"},{"id":"T2193","span":{"begin":608,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C0205436"},{"id":"T2194","span":{"begin":224,"end":232},"obj":"UMLS/C0205156"},{"id":"T2195","span":{"begin":691,"end":696},"obj":"UMLS/C0205437"},{"id":"T2196","span":{"begin":535,"end":544},"obj":"UMLS/C1522634"},{"id":"T2197","span":{"begin":554,"end":562},"obj":"UMLS/C1522634"},{"id":"T2198","span":{"begin":166,"end":169},"obj":"UMLS/C0006823"},{"id":"T2199","span":{"begin":145,"end":149},"obj":"UMLS/C1547310"},{"id":"T2200","span":{"begin":47,"end":58},"obj":"UMLS/C0031809"},{"id":"T2201","span":{"begin":353,"end":364},"obj":"UMLS/C1533716"},{"id":"T2202","span":{"begin":587,"end":598},"obj":"UMLS/C1533716"},{"id":"T2203","span":{"begin":353,"end":364},"obj":"UMLS/C1561527"},{"id":"T2204","span":{"begin":587,"end":598},"obj":"UMLS/C1561527"},{"id":"T2205","span":{"begin":529,"end":534},"obj":"UMLS/C0205449"},{"id":"T2206","span":{"begin":662,"end":665},"obj":"UMLS/C0205448"},{"id":"T2207","span":{"begin":174,"end":178},"obj":"UMLS/C0449719"},{"id":"T2208","span":{"begin":248,"end":255},"obj":"UMLS/C0919553"},{"id":"T2209","span":{"begin":353,"end":364},"obj":"UMLS/C1561528"},{"id":"T2210","span":{"begin":587,"end":598},"obj":"UMLS/C1561528"},{"id":"T2211","span":{"begin":166,"end":169},"obj":"UMLS/C0344312"},{"id":"T2212","span":{"begin":566,"end":571},"obj":"UMLS/C0037088"},{"id":"T2213","span":{"begin":161,"end":165},"obj":"UMLS/C0323983"},{"id":"T3297","span":{"begin":869,"end":876},"obj":"UMLS/C0560184"},{"id":"T3298","span":{"begin":807,"end":814},"obj":"UMLS/C1706244"},{"id":"T3299","span":{"begin":798,"end":805},"obj":"UMLS/C1280519"},{"id":"T3300","span":{"begin":807,"end":814},"obj":"UMLS/C1552616"},{"id":"T3301","span":{"begin":869,"end":876},"obj":"UMLS/C0205415"},{"id":"T3302","span":{"begin":939,"end":950},"obj":"UMLS/C0031928"},{"id":"T3303","span":{"begin":869,"end":876},"obj":"UMLS/C0560187"},{"id":"T3304","span":{"begin":822,"end":832},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T3305","span":{"begin":848,"end":858},"obj":"UMLS/C2698624"},{"id":"T3306","span":{"begin":798,"end":805},"obj":"UMLS/C0332294"},{"id":"T3307","span":{"begin":798,"end":805},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"},{"id":"T3308","span":{"begin":869,"end":876},"obj":"UMLS/C0014653"},{"id":"T3309","span":{"begin":798,"end":805},"obj":"UMLS/C1546471"},{"id":"T3310","span":{"begin":885,"end":893},"obj":"UMLS/C0814225"},{"id":"T3311","span":{"begin":923,"end":931},"obj":"UMLS/C1707959"},{"id":"T3312","span":{"begin":848,"end":858},"obj":"UMLS/C1707957"},{"id":"T3313","span":{"begin":807,"end":814},"obj":"UMLS/C2360088"}],"text":"Balance between benefits and harms\nThe graders assessments about the balance between benefits and harms are shown in Table 7. There is visibly a poor agreement, this can, in part, be explained by the accumulation of all the previous differences in grading of the quality and importance of the evidence. Some of the judges made assumptions or considered information that was not included in the evidence profiles. When we discussed these judgements, we reached a consensus about the balance between benefits and harms for all but three questions. For one question we found we needed more information. For the second judgement we disagreed about the importance of two of the outcomes. For the third judgement we disagreed about the relative values we attached to the benefits and the harms.\nTable 7 Results, summary of the judgements made by the 17 evaluators about the balance between benefits and harms for each of the 12 examples in the pilot study\n\nR"}