PMC:1084246 / 123-2360 JSONTXT

{"target":"https://pubannotation.org/docs/sourcedb/PMC/sourceid/1084246","sourcedb":"PMC","sourceid":"1084246","source_url":"http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/1084246","text":"Background\nSystems that are used by different organisations to grade the quality of evidence and the strength of recommendations vary. They have different strengths and weaknesses. The GRADE Working Group has developed an approach that addresses key shortcomings in these systems. The aim of this study was to pilot test and further develop the GRADE approach to grading evidence and recommendations.\n\nMethods\nA GRADE evidence profile consists of two tables: a quality assessment and a summary of findings. Twelve evidence profiles were used in this pilot study. Each evidence profile was made based on information available in a systematic review. Seventeen people were given instructions and independently graded the level of evidence and strength of recommendation for each of the 12 evidence profiles. For each example judgements were collected, summarised and discussed in the group with the aim of improving the proposed grading system. Kappas were calculated as a measure of chance-corrected agreement for the quality of evidence for each outcome for each of the twelve evidence profiles. The seventeen judges were also asked about the ease of understanding and the sensibility of the approach. All of the judgements were recorded and disagreements discussed.\n\nResults\nThere was a varied amount of agreement on the quality of evidence for the outcomes relating to each of the twelve questions (kappa coefficients for agreement beyond chance ranged from 0 to 0.82). However, there was fair agreement about the relative importance of each outcome. There was poor agreement about the balance of benefits and harms and recommendations. Most of the disagreements were easily resolved through discussion. In general we found the GRADE approach to be clear, understandable and sensible. Some modifications were made in the approach and it was agreed that more information was needed in the evidence profiles.\n\nConclusion\nJudgements about evidence and recommendations are complex. Some subjectivity, especially regarding recommendations, is unavoidable. We believe our system for guiding these complex judgements appropriately balances the need for simplicity with the need for full and transparent consideration of all important issues. ","divisions":[{"label":"Section","span":{"begin":0,"end":400}},{"label":"Title","span":{"begin":0,"end":10}},{"label":"Section","span":{"begin":402,"end":1266}},{"label":"Title","span":{"begin":402,"end":409}},{"label":"Section","span":{"begin":1268,"end":1908}},{"label":"Title","span":{"begin":1268,"end":1275}},{"label":"Section","span":{"begin":1910,"end":2236}},{"label":"Title","span":{"begin":1910,"end":1920}}],"tracks":[{"project":"biosemtest","denotations":[{"id":"T22","span":{"begin":918,"end":926},"obj":"UMLS/C1441414"},{"id":"T1","span":{"begin":1792,"end":1805},"obj":"UMLS/C1554963"},{"id":"T2","span":{"begin":451,"end":457},"obj":"UMLS/C1706074"},{"id":"T3","span":{"begin":451,"end":457},"obj":"UMLS/C1706073"},{"id":"T4","span":{"begin":641,"end":647},"obj":"UMLS/C1709941"},{"id":"T5","span":{"begin":1588,"end":1595},"obj":"UMLS/C0560184"},{"id":"T6","span":{"begin":2126,"end":2134},"obj":"UMLS/C0560184"},{"id":"T7","span":{"begin":641,"end":647},"obj":"UMLS/C1709940"},{"id":"T8","span":{"begin":486,"end":493},"obj":"UMLS/C1552616"},{"id":"T9","span":{"begin":1491,"end":1495},"obj":"UMLS/C1548785"},{"id":"T10","span":{"begin":1588,"end":1595},"obj":"UMLS/C0560187"},{"id":"T11","span":{"begin":2126,"end":2134},"obj":"UMLS/C0560187"},{"id":"T12","span":{"begin":641,"end":647},"obj":"UMLS/C1552617"},{"id":"T13","span":{"begin":1751,"end":1756},"obj":"UMLS/C0522503"},{"id":"T14","span":{"begin":2186,"end":2197},"obj":"UMLS/C0522503"},{"id":"T15","span":{"begin":402,"end":409},"obj":"UMLS/C0025663"},{"id":"T16","span":{"begin":402,"end":409},"obj":"UMLS/C0025664"},{"id":"T17","span":{"begin":1359,"end":1367},"obj":"UMLS/C0445223"},{"id":"T18","span":{"begin":2079,"end":2086},"obj":"UMLS/C1706050"},{"id":"T19","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C0947630"},{"id":"T20","span":{"begin":1694,"end":1704},"obj":"UMLS/C0557061"},{"id":"T21","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C1880279"},{"id":"T23","span":{"begin":486,"end":493},"obj":"UMLS/C2360088"},{"id":"T25","span":{"begin":84,"end":92},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T26","span":{"begin":371,"end":379},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T27","span":{"begin":418,"end":426},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T28","span":{"begin":514,"end":522},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T29","span":{"begin":568,"end":576},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T30","span":{"begin":787,"end":795},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T31","span":{"begin":1028,"end":1040},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T32","span":{"begin":1077,"end":1085},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T33","span":{"begin":1333,"end":1345},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T34","span":{"begin":1890,"end":1898},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T35","span":{"begin":1938,"end":1946},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T36","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1522242"},{"id":"T37","span":{"begin":971,"end":978},"obj":"UMLS/C0444706"},{"id":"T38","span":{"begin":60,"end":62},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T39","span":{"begin":307,"end":309},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T40","span":{"begin":360,"end":362},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T41","span":{"begin":1368,"end":1370},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T42","span":{"begin":1462,"end":1464},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T43","span":{"begin":1745,"end":1747},"obj":"UMLS/C0319022"},{"id":"T44","span":{"begin":927,"end":941},"obj":"UMLS/C1708250"},{"id":"T45","span":{"begin":1516,"end":1524},"obj":"UMLS/C1546849"},{"id":"T46","span":{"begin":1588,"end":1595},"obj":"UMLS/C0014653"},{"id":"T47","span":{"begin":2126,"end":2134},"obj":"UMLS/C0014653"},{"id":"T48","span":{"begin":1448,"end":1454},"obj":"UMLS/C2348147"},{"id":"T49","span":{"begin":955,"end":965},"obj":"UMLS/C0444686"},{"id":"T50","span":{"begin":1151,"end":1164},"obj":"UMLS/C0162340"},{"id":"T51","span":{"begin":1110,"end":1116},"obj":"UMLS/C0221191"},{"id":"T52","span":{"begin":1792,"end":1805},"obj":"UMLS/C0392747"},{"id":"T53","span":{"begin":236,"end":245},"obj":"UMLS/C1578437"},{"id":"T54","span":{"begin":169,"end":179},"obj":"UMLS/C0004093"},{"id":"T55","span":{"begin":1390,"end":1399},"obj":"UMLS/C0332147"},{"id":"T57","span":{"begin":101,"end":109},"obj":"UMLS/C0808080"},{"id":"T58","span":{"begin":155,"end":164},"obj":"UMLS/C0808080"},{"id":"T59","span":{"begin":741,"end":749},"obj":"UMLS/C0808080"},{"id":"T60","span":{"begin":236,"end":245},"obj":"UMLS/C1578436"},{"id":"T61","span":{"begin":469,"end":479},"obj":"UMLS/C1516048"},{"id":"T62","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1561557"},{"id":"T63","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C1880229"},{"id":"T64","span":{"begin":1563,"end":1567},"obj":"UMLS/C1561559"},{"id":"T65","span":{"begin":1563,"end":1567},"obj":"UMLS/C1561558"},{"id":"T66","span":{"begin":904,"end":913},"obj":"UMLS/C0332161"},{"id":"T67","span":{"begin":1229,"end":1237},"obj":"UMLS/C1548330"},{"id":"T68","span":{"begin":1359,"end":1367},"obj":"UMLS/C0439849"},{"id":"T69","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"UMLS/C0205172"},{"id":"T70","span":{"begin":316,"end":320},"obj":"UMLS/C0039593"},{"id":"T71","span":{"begin":469,"end":479},"obj":"UMLS/C1261322"},{"id":"T72","span":{"begin":1295,"end":1301},"obj":"UMLS/C1561574"},{"id":"T73","span":{"begin":1971,"end":1978},"obj":"UMLS/C0439855"},{"id":"T74","span":{"begin":2093,"end":2100},"obj":"UMLS/C0439855"},{"id":"T75","span":{"begin":1563,"end":1567},"obj":"UMLS/C1547310"},{"id":"T76","span":{"begin":169,"end":179},"obj":"UMLS/C1883552"},{"id":"T77","span":{"begin":285,"end":288},"obj":"UMLS/C1947946"},{"id":"T78","span":{"begin":897,"end":900},"obj":"UMLS/C1947946"},{"id":"T79","span":{"begin":316,"end":320},"obj":"UMLS/C0013702"},{"id":"T80","span":{"begin":603,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C1561527"},{"id":"T81","span":{"begin":1860,"end":1871},"obj":"UMLS/C1561527"},{"id":"T82","span":{"begin":1751,"end":1756},"obj":"UMLS/C0521097"},{"id":"T83","span":{"begin":316,"end":320},"obj":"UMLS/C0022885"},{"id":"T84","span":{"begin":1229,"end":1237},"obj":"UMLS/C0557033"},{"id":"T85","span":{"begin":603,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C1561528"},{"id":"T86","span":{"begin":1860,"end":1871},"obj":"UMLS/C1561528"},{"id":"T87","span":{"begin":236,"end":245},"obj":"UMLS/C1547327"},{"id":"T88","span":{"begin":191,"end":204},"obj":"UMLS/C1883562"},{"id":"T89","span":{"begin":641,"end":647},"obj":"UMLS/C0282443"},{"id":"T90","span":{"begin":671,"end":676},"obj":"UMLS/C1947971"},{"id":"T91","span":{"begin":1751,"end":1756},"obj":"UMLS/C1550016"},{"id":"T92","span":{"begin":246,"end":249},"obj":"UMLS/C1706198"},{"id":"T93","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C0178499"},{"id":"T94","span":{"begin":1751,"end":1756},"obj":"UMLS/C1550003"},{"id":"T96","span":{"begin":1441,"end":1447},"obj":"UMLS/C0237506"},{"id":"T97","span":{"begin":904,"end":913},"obj":"UMLS/C0184511"},{"id":"T98","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C2349977"},{"id":"T99","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C2603343"},{"id":"T100","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1552516"},{"id":"T101","span":{"begin":630,"end":640},"obj":"UMLS/C0220922"},{"id":"T103","span":{"begin":63,"end":68},"obj":"UMLS/C0441800"},{"id":"T104","span":{"begin":363,"end":370},"obj":"UMLS/C0441800"},{"id":"T105","span":{"begin":708,"end":714},"obj":"UMLS/C0441800"},{"id":"T106","span":{"begin":427,"end":434},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T107","span":{"begin":523,"end":531},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T108","span":{"begin":577,"end":584},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T109","span":{"begin":796,"end":804},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T110","span":{"begin":1086,"end":1094},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T111","span":{"begin":1899,"end":1907},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T112","span":{"begin":310,"end":315},"obj":"UMLS/C0473169"},{"id":"T113","span":{"begin":615,"end":624},"obj":"UMLS/C0470187"},{"id":"T114","span":{"begin":677,"end":689},"obj":"UMLS/C1292796"},{"id":"T115","span":{"begin":677,"end":689},"obj":"UMLS/C0220931"},{"id":"T116","span":{"begin":971,"end":978},"obj":"UMLS/C0242485"},{"id":"T117","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C0008976"},{"id":"T118","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C0008972"},{"id":"T119","span":{"begin":1268,"end":1275},"obj":"UMLS/C1280519"},{"id":"T120","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C1704464"},{"id":"T121","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C0441833"},{"id":"T122","span":{"begin":1599,"end":1607},"obj":"UMLS/C0814225"},{"id":"T123","span":{"begin":1563,"end":1567},"obj":"UMLS/C0542537"},{"id":"T124","span":{"begin":1229,"end":1237},"obj":"UMLS/C0034869"},{"id":"T126","span":{"begin":113,"end":128},"obj":"UMLS/C0034866"},{"id":"T127","span":{"begin":384,"end":399},"obj":"UMLS/C0034866"},{"id":"T128","span":{"begin":753,"end":767},"obj":"UMLS/C0034866"},{"id":"T129","span":{"begin":1622,"end":1637},"obj":"UMLS/C0034866"},{"id":"T130","span":{"begin":1951,"end":1966},"obj":"UMLS/C0034866"},{"id":"T131","span":{"begin":2020,"end":2035},"obj":"UMLS/C0034866"},{"id":"T132","span":{"begin":719,"end":736},"obj":"UMLS/C0393009"},{"id":"T133","span":{"begin":1390,"end":1399},"obj":"UMLS/C1522634"},{"id":"T134","span":{"begin":1491,"end":1495},"obj":"UMLS/C1547189"},{"id":"T135","span":{"begin":486,"end":493},"obj":"UMLS/C1706244"},{"id":"T136","span":{"begin":497,"end":505},"obj":"UMLS/C2607943"},{"id":"T137","span":{"begin":839,"end":848},"obj":"UMLS/C1516695"},{"id":"T138","span":{"begin":1694,"end":1704},"obj":"UMLS/C2584313"},{"id":"T139","span":{"begin":971,"end":978},"obj":"UMLS/C1879489"},{"id":"T140","span":{"begin":677,"end":689},"obj":"UMLS/C0039401"},{"id":"T141","span":{"begin":222,"end":230},"obj":"UMLS/C1292724"},{"id":"T142","span":{"begin":351,"end":359},"obj":"UMLS/C1292724"},{"id":"T143","span":{"begin":1192,"end":1200},"obj":"UMLS/C1292724"},{"id":"T144","span":{"begin":1736,"end":1744},"obj":"UMLS/C1292724"},{"id":"T145","span":{"begin":1823,"end":1831},"obj":"UMLS/C1292724"},{"id":"T146","span":{"begin":839,"end":848},"obj":"UMLS/C1516698"},{"id":"T147","span":{"begin":469,"end":479},"obj":"UMLS/C0679207"},{"id":"T148","span":{"begin":36,"end":45},"obj":"UMLS/C1705242"},{"id":"T149","span":{"begin":145,"end":154},"obj":"UMLS/C1705242"},{"id":"T150","span":{"begin":1516,"end":1524},"obj":"UMLS/C0205345"},{"id":"T151","span":{"begin":823,"end":833},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T152","span":{"begin":1213,"end":1223},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T153","span":{"begin":1921,"end":1931},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T154","span":{"begin":2101,"end":2111},"obj":"UMLS/C0022423"},{"id":"T155","span":{"begin":2079,"end":2086},"obj":"UMLS/C0302614"},{"id":"T156","span":{"begin":1709,"end":1716},"obj":"UMLS/C1553889"},{"id":"T157","span":{"begin":671,"end":676},"obj":"UMLS/C1550718"},{"id":"T158","span":{"begin":451,"end":457},"obj":"UMLS/C0039224"},{"id":"T159","span":{"begin":815,"end":822},"obj":"UMLS/C1707959"},{"id":"T160","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C0557651"},{"id":"T161","span":{"begin":1448,"end":1454},"obj":"UMLS/C1514721"},{"id":"T163","span":{"begin":205,"end":208},"obj":"UMLS/C2348947"},{"id":"T164","span":{"begin":918,"end":926},"obj":"UMLS/C1553874"},{"id":"T165","span":{"begin":316,"end":320},"obj":"UMLS/C0183885"},{"id":"T168","span":{"begin":11,"end":18},"obj":"UMLS/C1704459"},{"id":"T169","span":{"begin":272,"end":279},"obj":"UMLS/C1704459"},{"id":"T170","span":{"begin":2068,"end":2074},"obj":"UMLS/C1704459"},{"id":"T171","span":{"begin":671,"end":676},"obj":"UMLS/C1442162"},{"id":"T172","span":{"begin":1855,"end":1859},"obj":"UMLS/C0439064"},{"id":"T173","span":{"begin":659,"end":665},"obj":"UMLS/C0027361"},{"id":"T174","span":{"begin":677,"end":689},"obj":"UMLS/C0302828"},{"id":"T175","span":{"begin":0,"end":10},"obj":"UMLS/C1706907"},{"id":"T176","span":{"begin":971,"end":978},"obj":"UMLS/C0079809"},{"id":"T177","span":{"begin":1407,"end":1419},"obj":"UMLS/C1707429"},{"id":"T178","span":{"begin":46,"end":59},"obj":"UMLS/C1522486"},{"id":"T179","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C1549548"},{"id":"T180","span":{"begin":316,"end":320},"obj":"UMLS/C0392366"},{"id":"T181","span":{"begin":1588,"end":1595},"obj":"UMLS/C0205415"},{"id":"T182","span":{"begin":2126,"end":2134},"obj":"UMLS/C0205415"},{"id":"T183","span":{"begin":943,"end":949},"obj":"UMLS/C0439099"},{"id":"T184","span":{"begin":1401,"end":1406},"obj":"UMLS/C0439099"},{"id":"T185","span":{"begin":1229,"end":1237},"obj":"UMLS/C1553414"},{"id":"T188","span":{"begin":11,"end":18},"obj":"UMLS/C0449913"},{"id":"T189","span":{"begin":272,"end":279},"obj":"UMLS/C0449913"},{"id":"T190","span":{"begin":2068,"end":2074},"obj":"UMLS/C0449913"},{"id":"T191","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1257890"},{"id":"T192","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C1626935"},{"id":"T193","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1552839"},{"id":"T194","span":{"begin":46,"end":59},"obj":"UMLS/C0029237"},{"id":"T195","span":{"begin":850,"end":860},"obj":"UMLS/C1553398"},{"id":"T196","span":{"begin":46,"end":59},"obj":"UMLS/C0029246"},{"id":"T197","span":{"begin":955,"end":965},"obj":"UMLS/C1443182"},{"id":"T198","span":{"begin":507,"end":513},"obj":"UMLS/C0205458"},{"id":"T199","span":{"begin":1070,"end":1076},"obj":"UMLS/C0205458"},{"id":"T200","span":{"begin":1383,"end":1389},"obj":"UMLS/C0205458"},{"id":"T203","span":{"begin":11,"end":18},"obj":"UMLS/C1553451"},{"id":"T204","span":{"begin":272,"end":279},"obj":"UMLS/C1553451"},{"id":"T205","span":{"begin":2068,"end":2074},"obj":"UMLS/C1553451"},{"id":"T206","span":{"begin":246,"end":249},"obj":"UMLS/C1554080"},{"id":"T207","span":{"begin":603,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C1533716"},{"id":"T208","span":{"begin":1860,"end":1871},"obj":"UMLS/C1533716"},{"id":"T209","span":{"begin":1677,"end":1685},"obj":"UMLS/C2699488"},{"id":"T210","span":{"begin":447,"end":450},"obj":"UMLS/C0205448"},{"id":"T211","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C1550601"},{"id":"T213","span":{"begin":63,"end":68},"obj":"UMLS/C0919553"},{"id":"T214","span":{"begin":363,"end":370},"obj":"UMLS/C0919553"},{"id":"T215","span":{"begin":708,"end":714},"obj":"UMLS/C0919553"},{"id":"T216","span":{"begin":1229,"end":1237},"obj":"UMLS/C2355580"},{"id":"T217","span":{"begin":402,"end":409},"obj":"UMLS/C0449851"},{"id":"T218","span":{"begin":2177,"end":2181},"obj":"UMLS/C0443225"},{"id":"T219","span":{"begin":1720,"end":1725},"obj":"UMLS/C0037088"},{"id":"T220","span":{"begin":641,"end":647},"obj":"UMLS/C1704362"},{"id":"T221","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C0439745"},{"id":"T222","span":{"begin":1516,"end":1524},"obj":"UMLS/C1547039"},{"id":"T224","span":{"begin":101,"end":109},"obj":"UMLS/C1705922"},{"id":"T225","span":{"begin":155,"end":164},"obj":"UMLS/C1705922"},{"id":"T226","span":{"begin":741,"end":749},"obj":"UMLS/C1705922"},{"id":"T227","span":{"begin":904,"end":913},"obj":"UMLS/C1272745"},{"id":"T228","span":{"begin":297,"end":302},"obj":"UMLS/C1705923"},{"id":"T229","span":{"begin":1971,"end":1978},"obj":"UMLS/C1704241"},{"id":"T230","span":{"begin":2093,"end":2100},"obj":"UMLS/C1704241"},{"id":"T231","span":{"begin":603,"end":614},"obj":"UMLS/C0870705"},{"id":"T232","span":{"begin":1860,"end":1871},"obj":"UMLS/C0870705"},{"id":"T233","span":{"begin":594,"end":599},"obj":"UMLS/C1705938"},{"id":"T234","span":{"begin":236,"end":245},"obj":"UMLS/C1442065"},{"id":"T235","span":{"begin":999,"end":1008},"obj":"UMLS/C0680240"},{"id":"T236","span":{"begin":1305,"end":1314},"obj":"UMLS/C0680240"},{"id":"T237","span":{"begin":1424,"end":1433},"obj":"UMLS/C0680240"},{"id":"T238","span":{"begin":1496,"end":1505},"obj":"UMLS/C0680240"},{"id":"T239","span":{"begin":1568,"end":1577},"obj":"UMLS/C0680240"},{"id":"T240","span":{"begin":1242,"end":1255},"obj":"UMLS/C0680238"},{"id":"T241","span":{"begin":1651,"end":1664},"obj":"UMLS/C0680238"},{"id":"T242","span":{"begin":222,"end":230},"obj":"UMLS/C0449445"},{"id":"T243","span":{"begin":351,"end":359},"obj":"UMLS/C0449445"},{"id":"T244","span":{"begin":1192,"end":1200},"obj":"UMLS/C0449445"},{"id":"T245","span":{"begin":1736,"end":1744},"obj":"UMLS/C0449445"},{"id":"T246","span":{"begin":1823,"end":1831},"obj":"UMLS/C0449445"},{"id":"T248","span":{"begin":73,"end":80},"obj":"UMLS/C0332306"},{"id":"T249","span":{"begin":461,"end":468},"obj":"UMLS/C0332306"},{"id":"T250","span":{"begin":1017,"end":1024},"obj":"UMLS/C0332306"},{"id":"T251","span":{"begin":1322,"end":1329},"obj":"UMLS/C0332306"},{"id":"T253","span":{"begin":550,"end":561},"obj":"UMLS/C0031928"},{"id":"T254","span":{"begin":1720,"end":1725},"obj":"UMLS/C0243095"},{"id":"T255","span":{"begin":1563,"end":1567},"obj":"UMLS/C2700379"},{"id":"T256","span":{"begin":1876,"end":1882},"obj":"UMLS/C0027552"},{"id":"T257","span":{"begin":1046,"end":1053},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"},{"id":"T258","span":{"begin":1268,"end":1275},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"},{"id":"T259","span":{"begin":1350,"end":1358},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"},{"id":"T260","span":{"begin":1544,"end":1551},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"},{"id":"T261","span":{"begin":1268,"end":1275},"obj":"UMLS/C0332294"},{"id":"T262","span":{"begin":1516,"end":1524},"obj":"UMLS/C0080103"},{"id":"T263","span":{"begin":2139,"end":2147},"obj":"UMLS/C0686904"},{"id":"T264","span":{"begin":2168,"end":2176},"obj":"UMLS/C0686904"},{"id":"T265","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1705428"},{"id":"T266","span":{"begin":955,"end":965},"obj":"UMLS/C1441506"},{"id":"T267","span":{"begin":1709,"end":1716},"obj":"UMLS/C0205246"},{"id":"T268","span":{"begin":1677,"end":1685},"obj":"UMLS/C1514893"},{"id":"T269","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"UMLS/C1705429"},{"id":"T270","span":{"begin":918,"end":926},"obj":"UMLS/C1578820"},{"id":"T271","span":{"begin":129,"end":133},"obj":"UMLS/C1548673"},{"id":"T272","span":{"begin":1288,"end":1294},"obj":"UMLS/C1548673"},{"id":"T273","span":{"begin":1563,"end":1567},"obj":"UMLS/C0032854"},{"id":"T274","span":{"begin":904,"end":913},"obj":"UMLS/C0332272"},{"id":"T275","span":{"begin":1359,"end":1367},"obj":"UMLS/C1704787"},{"id":"T276","span":{"begin":641,"end":647},"obj":"UMLS/C0699752"},{"id":"T277","span":{"begin":310,"end":315},"obj":"UMLS/C0453947"},{"id":"T278","span":{"begin":1173,"end":1184},"obj":"UMLS/C0439823"},{"id":"T279","span":{"begin":285,"end":288},"obj":"UMLS/C0337858"},{"id":"T280","span":{"begin":897,"end":900},"obj":"UMLS/C0337858"},{"id":"T281","span":{"begin":1268,"end":1275},"obj":"UMLS/C1546471"},{"id":"T282","span":{"begin":1910,"end":1920},"obj":"UMLS/C1707478"},{"id":"T283","span":{"begin":1295,"end":1301},"obj":"UMLS/C1265611"},{"id":"T284","span":{"begin":469,"end":479},"obj":"UMLS/C0031809"},{"id":"T285","span":{"begin":1359,"end":1367},"obj":"UMLS/C0163712"},{"id":"T286","span":{"begin":677,"end":689},"obj":"UMLS/C1442085"},{"id":"T288","span":{"begin":2079,"end":2086},"obj":"UMLS/C0181090"},{"id":"T289","span":{"begin":1670,"end":1676},"obj":"UMLS/C0332219"},{"id":"T290","span":{"begin":236,"end":245},"obj":"UMLS/C0376649"},{"id":"T291","span":{"begin":904,"end":913},"obj":"UMLS/C1561611"},{"id":"T292","span":{"begin":292,"end":296},"obj":"UMLS/C0323983"},{"id":"T293","span":{"begin":545,"end":549},"obj":"UMLS/C0323983"},{"id":"T663","span":{"begin":787,"end":795},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T762","span":{"begin":796,"end":804},"obj":"UMLS/C1979963"},{"id":"T1734","span":{"begin":1028,"end":1040},"obj":"UMLS/C0332120"},{"id":"T1827","span":{"begin":1017,"end":1024},"obj":"UMLS/C0332306"},{"id":"T1838","span":{"begin":1046,"end":1053},"obj":"UMLS/C1274040"}],"attributes":[{"subj":"T22","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T1","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T2","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T3","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T4","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T5","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T6","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T7","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T8","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T9","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T10","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T11","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T12","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T13","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T14","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T15","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T16","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T17","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T18","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T19","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T20","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T21","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T23","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T25","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T26","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T27","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T28","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T29","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T30","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T31","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T32","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T33","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T34","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T35","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T36","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T37","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T38","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T39","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T40","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T41","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T42","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T43","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T44","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T45","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T46","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T47","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T48","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T49","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T50","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T51","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T52","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T53","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T54","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T55","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T57","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T58","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T59","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T60","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T61","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T62","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T63","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T64","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T65","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T66","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T67","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T68","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T69","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T70","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T71","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T72","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T73","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T74","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T75","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T76","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T77","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T78","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T79","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T80","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T81","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T82","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T83","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T84","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T85","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T86","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T87","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T88","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T89","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T90","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T91","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T92","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T93","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T94","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T96","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T97","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T98","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T99","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T100","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T101","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T103","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T104","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T105","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T106","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T107","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T108","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T109","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T110","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T111","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T112","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T113","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T114","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T115","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T116","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T117","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T118","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T119","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T120","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T121","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T122","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T123","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T124","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T126","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T127","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T128","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T129","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T130","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T131","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T132","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T133","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T134","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T135","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T136","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T137","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T138","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T139","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T140","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T141","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T142","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T143","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T144","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T145","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T146","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T147","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T148","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T149","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T150","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T151","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T152","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T153","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T154","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T155","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T156","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T157","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T158","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T159","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T160","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T161","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T163","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T164","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T165","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T168","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T169","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T170","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T171","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T172","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T173","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T174","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T175","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T176","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T177","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T178","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T179","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T180","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T181","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T182","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T183","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T184","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T185","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T188","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T189","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T190","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T191","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T192","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T193","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T194","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T195","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T196","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T197","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T198","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T199","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T200","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T203","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T204","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T205","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T206","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T207","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T208","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T209","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T210","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T211","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T213","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T214","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T215","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T216","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T217","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T218","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T219","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T220","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T221","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T222","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T224","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T225","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T226","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T227","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T228","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T229","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T230","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T231","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T232","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T233","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T234","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T235","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T236","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T237","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T238","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T239","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T240","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T241","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T242","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T243","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T244","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T245","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T246","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T248","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T249","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T250","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T251","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T253","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T254","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T255","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T256","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T257","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T258","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T259","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T260","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T261","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T262","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T263","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T264","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T265","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T266","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T267","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T268","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T269","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T270","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T271","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T272","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T273","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T274","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T275","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T276","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T277","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T278","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T279","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T280","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T281","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T282","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T283","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T284","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T285","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T286","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T288","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T289","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T290","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T291","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T292","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T293","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T663","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T762","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T1734","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T1827","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"},{"subj":"T1838","pred":"source","obj":"biosemtest"}]},{"project":"NEUROSES","denotations":[{"id":"T309","span":{"begin":73,"end":80},"obj":"PATO_0000001"},{"id":"T310","span":{"begin":461,"end":468},"obj":"PATO_0000001"},{"id":"T311","span":{"begin":1017,"end":1024},"obj":"PATO_0000001"},{"id":"T312","span":{"begin":1322,"end":1329},"obj":"PATO_0000001"},{"id":"T313","span":{"begin":101,"end":109},"obj":"PATO_0001230"},{"id":"T314","span":{"begin":741,"end":749},"obj":"PATO_0001230"},{"id":"T315","span":{"begin":199,"end":204},"obj":"CHEBI_24433"},{"id":"T316","span":{"begin":882,"end":887},"obj":"CHEBI_24433"},{"id":"T317","span":{"begin":1588,"end":1595},"obj":"PATO_0000185"},{"id":"T318","span":{"begin":1588,"end":1595},"obj":"CHEBI_3612"},{"id":"T319","span":{"begin":1751,"end":1756},"obj":"PATO_0000964"},{"id":"T320","span":{"begin":2186,"end":2197},"obj":"PATO_0000964"},{"id":"T321","span":{"begin":1971,"end":1978},"obj":"PATO_0001504"}],"attributes":[{"subj":"T309","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T310","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T311","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T312","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T313","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T314","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T315","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T316","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T317","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T318","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T319","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T320","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"},{"subj":"T321","pred":"source","obj":"NEUROSES"}]}],"config":{"attribute types":[{"pred":"source","value type":"selection","values":[{"id":"biosemtest","color":"#ca93ec","default":true},{"id":"NEUROSES","color":"#93ecb0"}]}]}}